INDICTMENT AGAINST SRI LANKA
The Charge is Ethnic Cleansing
HOSPITAL MASSACRE BY INDIAN ARMY
ON DEEPAVALI DAY, OCTOBER 1987 [See also Rajiv Gandhi's War
Crimes]
An eyewitness account
...21 October 1987
From the
Broken Palmyra
V. Thangavelu Canada, 27
February 2001
Jaffna medical staff massacred by IPKF
remembered - 2003
17th
Anniversary of IPKF Jaffna Hospital
massacre, 22 October 2004
18th
Anniversary of IPKF Jaffna Hospital
Massacre, 21 October 2005
"The Indian Army came firing
into the Radiology Block and
fired indiscriminately at this
whole mass of people huddled
together. We saw patients dying.
We lay there without moving a
finger pretending to be dead. We
were wondering all the time
whether we would be burnt or shot
when the bodies of the dead were
collected ... "
|
கடமையின்
போது
உயிர்
நீத்த
ஊழியர்கள்
|
Dr A. Sivapathasuntheram, Dr
M.K. Ganesharatnam, Dr
Parimelalahar, Mrs Vadivelu,
Matron, Mrs Leelawathie, Nurse,
Mrs Sivapakiam, Nurse, Mrs
Ramanathan, Nurse, Mr
Shanmugalingam, Ambulance Driver,
Mr Kanagalingam, Telephone
Operator, Mr Krishnarajah, Works
Supervisor, Mr Selvarajah, Works
Supervisor
|
|
21-22
October 1987
|
|
An eyewitness account
... |
"It was a Diwali day - 21 October 1987. In
the history of Tamils it will come to be
regarded as a "dark day". Due to the
military offensive started by the IPKF on
the 10th day of October 1987, many
hospitals were not functioning, and there
were no transport facilities. There was a
tense situation prevailing as many innocent
civilians had been either killed or
wounded. Jaffna General Hospital was still
functioning in midst of hardships.
But the barbaric acts carried out by the
IPKF inside the Jaffna Hospital on that day
killed many. The dead included those at
work - in the X ray building, doctors in
the resting room, in doctors' offices, in
guest houses of the doctors, and also all
those injured civilians who had been
brought there from all over the
peninsula.
Dr.C.K.Ganesaratnam who finished his
medical studies at the Jaffna University
and working as a Surgeon at Jaffna General
hospital, Dr. Parimezhakar, head nurse Mrs.
P.Vadivelu, nurse Mrs.Mangaitkarasi, the
superviors at Leelavati Private Nursing
Home- Mr.Selvaraja, S.Seevaratnam,
Ambulance Driver V.Shanmugalingam, and
active workers at the Jaffna General
Hospital Mr.Peter, Mr.M.Thurairasa were
among those killed on the spot by the
IPKF.
An infant and few other children also
became the victims of the IPKF when they
made noise, watching these horrors. Struck
by a heart attack an aged civlian died died
singing the "sivapuraaNam" Barrels and
barrels of bullets were spent on innocent
patients who tried to seek help. They did
the same to the children and the aged who
asked for water.
On the next morning, 22 October 1987,
Dr.Sivapathasuntharam, who had unknowingly
came into hospital premises attempted to
save his injured coworkers, was killed by
the army personnel who were on guard. The
next day the IPKF collected all the dead
bodies and burnt all the bodies at the back
of the mortuary.
A total of 68
innocent Tamils were killed during
this particular barbaric offensive of the
IPKF. This number included three Doctors,
three nurses, seventeen coworkers at the
Jaffna hospital and others were the
patients admitted to the hospital.
The killings of Dr.Sivapathasuntharam
and other doctors who continued to serve
the Tamil community unlike the other
doctors who fled to alien lands after 1983
riots has become a dark spot in the history
of Tamil people. "
|
From the Broken
Palmyra |
From The Broken Palmyra - The
Tamil Crisis in Sri Lanka: An Inside
Account By Rajan Hoole, Daya
Somasundaram, K.Sritharan and Rajani
Thiranagama.1990 pp 265-271 [Book is
available on line at http://www.uthr.org/BP/Content.htm]
The War of October 1987 (India's
Disarming Operation - Jaffna
Hospital
"...An attempt by the Indian Army to
capture Jaffna Town had been expected for a
few days. For this reason many members of
the staff had kept away. Others thought the
Indian Army would be considerate and stayed
on performing necessary functions. Many
injured by shelling and many of those
wounded kept on arriving at the hospital.
Medicines were in short supply, making
surgery difficult. Over 70 dead bodies were
said to be piled up in the mortuary.
A false sense of security prevailed
because the intensity of shelling had been
noticeably reduced after a telephone call
made from the G.A.'s office to the Indian
Embassy by leading citizens in Jaffna. They
telephoned on 13 October (1987) complaining about the shelling
and aerial bombing. According to these
sources the Indian Embassy had denied that
they had any knowledge of such military
action which was bound to cause grievous
harm to civilians.
The environs of the hospital came
under cannon fire from the Fort and from
overhead helicopters at 11:00 a.m. on 21
October - Deepavali day.
A shell fell on the O.P.D. building at
11:30 a.m.. The O.P.D. officer went running
to the administration building and informed
a Consultant of what had happened. At 1:00
p.m. the Consultant was informed that
Indian troops had been sighted at the top
of Shanti Theatre Lane. At 1:30 p.m. a
shell fell on Ward 8 killing 7 persons. The
Consultant who went out with another doctor
to survey the situation spotted some empty
cartridges suggesting that persons had been
firing from inside the hospital
premises.
At 2:00 p.m. the Consultant's attention
was drawn to the presence of some armed
L.T.T.E. men inside the hospital premises.
The Consultant went with Dr. Ganesharatnam
and requested them to leave, pointing out
the danger they would cause the inmates.
The leader of the group agreed and they
went away. 5 minutes later the Consultant
was informed that another group of L.T.T.E.
men had come inside. Dr. Ganesharatnam
requested that the Consultant go with
someone else this time as he was, because
of his outspokenness, already having a
problematic relationship with the L.T.T.E..
The Consultant went this time with one of
the lady doctors and spoke to the L.T.T.E.
party. According to the Consultant, they
agreed to go and "disappeared from
sight."
There was a lull after 2.00 p.m..
According to this Consultant:
"I really did not
know what advice to give those in
the hospital. If I had known it was
safe to go, I would have advised
everyone to leave. But this was by
no means certain because there was
a curfew on and the army was near
at hand. My decision to leave was
mainly on the consideration that I
was hungry and the decision to
chance it was casually taken. I
left through the back entrance at
2:30 p.m. with one of my colleagues
and reached home without
incident.
"At about 4 p.m. we heard
shooting again for 15 to 20 minutes
from the vicinity of the petrol
shed on Hospital Road. There was no
retaliatory fire from the hospital.
At that time, to our knowledge
there were no Tigers in the
hospital."
|
Thus begins the story of the harrowing
experience of the resident doctors of this
foremost and biggest hospital in the war
torn North. One of them went on with their
terrible tale:
"We were in the radiology block in
the tea room at that time. The
whole place was crammed with people
including the patients from the
evacuated ward 7 as well. We heard
the noise of firing coming closer.
But we were sure that even if the
Indian Army entered, they would
check us, and then explanations
could be offered. Dr. Ganesharatnam
who was with us went out of the
room. Some of our colleagues were
still in the wards. The noise of
the firing was drawing very close.
All around us was the noise of
firing. We realised the danger and
lay flat on the floor.
The Indian Army came firing
into the Radiology Block and fired
indiscriminately at this whole mass
of people huddled together. We saw
patients dying. We lay there
without moving a finger pretending
to be dead. We were wondering all
the time whether we would be burnt
or shot when the bodies of the dead
were collected ...
In the night we heard few bursts
of fire. Most of the time we heard
them moving on the floor above,
where out quarters were situated.
We were like this for almost 18
hours until 11:00 a.m. the next
day."
|
Another of them took over the
narration:
"The Indian Army entered through
the out gate, came up along the
corridor and fired
indiscriminately. They fired into
the Overseer's office, and into
other offices. I saw many of my
fellow workers die... Another
worker whispered to me: ' Keep
lying down and do not move'.
"So we lay down quietly,
under one of the dead bodies,
throughout the night. One of
the overseers had a cough and he
groaned and coughed once in a way
in the night. One Indian soldier,
threw a grenade at this man killing
some more persons. I know the
ambulance driver died. In another
spot one man got up with his hand
up and cried out: "We are innocent.
We are supporters of Indira
Gandhi." A grenade was thrown at
him. He and his brother next to him
died.
The night passed by, and the
morning dawned. Still it was
absolutely tense. At about 8:30
a.m., Dr. Sivapathasundaram, the
Paediatrician, came walking along
the corridor with 3 nurses. He had
convinced them that they should
identify themselves and surrender.
They were walking with their hands
up shouting: "We surrender, we are
innocent doctors and nurses."
|
Dr. Sivapathasundaram was gunned down
point blank and the nurses injured. He was
a man who had come to save the lives of the
children and neonates marooned in the
hospital. His dedication was replied with
violence and death in the hands of this
army from a country that called itself the
champion of peace and nonviolence.
Those who survived continued to lay
among the dead, as if dead, until 11:00
a.m. the following day.
The residents said they were rescued
only when an officer turned up at one of
the wards and was confronted by a lady
doctor there. This doctor explained the
situation to the officer and later on came
to where they were with the army, holding
her hands up. She had called out to her
colleagues and those who were injured. They
found their colleague Dr. Ganesharatnam
with a stethoscope lying dead.
When the residents went up to their
rooms saw the whole place ransacked - with
bloodied boot marks on their clothing
scattered on the floor. They had lost all
their valuables. Later they continued work
- but a guard was at their door. They were
absolutely terror stricken those days.
Another resident doctor picked up the
story:
"I lay along the corridor leading
away from the foyer of the
Radiology Bock. My legs were
sticking out and evening sunlight
coming through an open window was
falling on it. I was scared and lay
as stiff as possible making sure
that no movement could be seen ...I
am indeed fortunate to have
survived. The soldiers threw a
grenade, and in the morning I
discovered that all the people
lying in front of me were dead. The
blasting grenades made tremendous
noises as if bombs were exploding.
Then the debris and dust would
settle on us and cake in the fresh
blood of those dead and injured.
All through the night as I lay
awake I heard noises, voices, an
occasional spray of shooting above
our heads or a grenade thrown. I
heard a child cry: "Amma (mother),
tea, tea, tea."
Another baby screamed. I thought
maybe the mother had died. Another
woman said: "My legs are numb. They
are cold. There is a corpse on it.
Please remove it." Unable to bear
her moans, I shouted: "Please
anybody near her, can't you remove
the corpse? Are you deaf?"
The woman continued to moan ...
till in the morning I knew the
reason for the silence. All those
around and the woman herself were
dead. One man was reciting the
Hindu religious work, the
Sivapuranam, and was calling
out:"Long live Rajiv. Long live
Indira Gandhi."
In the morning we found him the
victim of a grenade blast. Then we
discovered that there were a few
others who had survived in the
toilet. We whispered together:
Hearing about all this, maybe the
Director of the hospital and the
others would come over immediately
and rescue us from the hospital ...
They were all in the refugee camps.
So most probably they could get
together, complain, and perhaps
come out as a group, all of them
holding white flags. They will then
rescue us. Let's wait for the
morning...
And we waited eagerly from the
dawn to break. We were indeed very
hopeful. At about 8:00 or 8:30 on
the 22nd ... I heard Dr.
Sivapathasuntheram's voice. He was
shouting as he was coming along:
"We are innocent doctors and
nurses. We surrender. We
surrender..."
As he turned into the foyer,
we saw the soldier on the stairs
leading from the foyer shoot
repeatedly. Dr. Sivapathasuntharam
was dead ...
We saw later that the nurses
whom he had pushed down on either
side of him had escaped with
injuries. Now we knew that our fate
was sealed. We lay there awaiting
death.
Later on, around 10:30 or 11:00
a.m., we heard our co-resident, a
woman doctor, her voice calling out
to the living and the injured to
get up with their hands held up. I
thought only six of us in the room
had survived, but I found out that
at least 10 of us were there. All
of us with our hands up were
walking out of the room. We stepped
over the dead bodies that were in
front of us. They seemed to stretch
over almost a mile. They must have
acted as a deterrent to the
Indians' coming close to us. That's
why we survived ... Some of us
started crying. Then the only
Consultant amongst us, quietened us
down. He told us: "Do not cry .,,
this is not the hour for crying. We
have lost so much, so many. But we
have tasks, enormous tasks to do.
Let us keep together and work."
We know that if he had not said
so, we would have been totally
demoralised. It was this spirit of
courage and dedication of this
small band of doctors, nurses and
other employees that made Jaffna
Hospital unique and placed it
proudly among the hospitals that
functioned under siege, despair and
fear. I was reminded of hospital in
the camp of Bourj al Barajneh,
Beruit under the Imal siege."
|
So it was from the 22nd to the 29th of
October, that this band of persons with all
their anxieties attended to the wounded day
and night single handedly. As the surgeon
said:
"I did not know what happened to
my wife and two small daughters. I
had left them at the refugee camp ...
After the first two days we knew we
are not going to be killed in cold
blood. That was a relief. We knew we
were walking on a tight rope ...
between life and death ... I used to
lose my temper, my anger burst out
... as we saw many shells hit
patients. We also had Indian Army men
injured by land mines.. totally
smashed up. We were asked to treat
them as well. For us doctors, the
moment they come into the hospital
they were patients. They were the
sick ... and our duties were
dear." |
As he was talking to us pouring out his
harrowing tale, characteristically spiced
with his sense of humor, we knew the spirit
of medical care that pervaded this hospital
in the war torn city of Jaffna.
This ordeal is unprecedented especially
when viewed in the light of the earlier
pronouncements of the Indian Red Cross on
how a hospital should be treated even in
war time - that was when Sri Lankan forces
were around. Many questions were hanging
unanswered. Why was no attempt to evacuate,
warn or isolate the sick and the stall'
make? Why was the hospital not surrounded?
Why was the Indian entry into the hospital
made only through the front, thus leaving
the back of the hospital open for those who
wanted to escape to do so - while the sick
and those who cared for the sick remained
behind to be killed?
It is true that the Tigers were there
earlier in the day. One person said that he
had seen them hanging their clothing to
dry. Another saw a few arms left behind on
the premises.
Be that as it may, why did the
professional army of a great nation storm a
civilian hospital, with such callous
disregard for both international covenants
and the cost in human lives which may never
be determined precisely.
The Indian authorities seem to have
decided that there will be no public
inquiry into the incident..."
|
V.
Thangavelu Canada, 27 February 2001 |
"My thanks to Sachi Sri Kantha for
recapitulating the
summary execution of Dr.K. Visvaranjan by the
Sri Lanka army. There are hundreds, if
not thousands, who met similar fate like Dr.
K. Visvaranjan but remain unheard, unsung and
unwept. The same goes to the doctors,
nurses and hospital staff gunned down without
any provocation by the murderous IPKF on
October 21, 1987. The tragedy is that
none of the perpetrators of these dastardly
crimes were ever brought to justice.
Politicians like G.K.Moopanar and journalists
like N.Ram and Cho are still mourning the
demise of Rajiv Gandhi who despatched
the murderous IPKF on a killing spree, when
they have no tears for the thousands of
innocent Tamils who perished like
Dr.K.Visvaranjan..." |
17th
Anniversary of IPKF Jaffna Hospital massacre
commemorated, 22 October 2004
|
Seventeenth death anniversary of
twenty-one persons including medical
specialists, nurses, attendants, patients and
members of public who were massacred inside
Jaffna Teaching Hospital (JTH) by Indian
Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) troops stationed
in Jaffna Fort on 21st October, 1987 was
observed Thursday in the hospital premises,
civil sources said. Medical Superintendent
of the JTH Dr.Sathurmugam presided over the
event attended by medical officers, nurses,
hospital employees and members of public.
Nallur Division Head of the Liberation Tigers
of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) Mr.Cheliyan also
attended the event.
Participants offered flowers in front of the
photographs of those massacred by Indian
troops who arrived in Sri Lanka after the
signing of the Indo-Sri Lankan peace accord
by then President of Sri Lanka
Mr.J.R.Jayawardene and Indian Prime Minister
Mr.Rajiv Gandhi.
The victims of the massacre included three
leading medical specialists at that time,
Dr.A.Sivapathasuntharam, Dr.K.Parimelalahar
and Dr.K.Ganesharatnam, three nurses and
fifteen other employees. |
18th
Anniversary of Massacre commemorated in
Jaffna Hospital, 21 October 2005 |
Eighteenth death anniversary of twenty-one
persons including medical specialists,
nurses, attendants, patients and members of
public who were massacred inside Jaffna
Teaching Hospital (JTH) by Indian Peace
Keeping Force (IPKF) troops stationed in
Jaffna Fort on 21st October, 1987 was held
at the Jaffna Teaching Hospital Friday,
sources in Jaffna said. Deputy Director of
the Hospital, R Raviraj, presided the
event.Eye surgeon Dr V Sivanthan, Hospital
Treasurer Mr Suthanthirapalan, relatives of
the victims and Hospital workers lit the
common flame.
Workers and relatives
garlanded and paid floral tribute to the
picture frames of the twenty one
victims.
Several doctors at the spoke at the
function accusing the Indian army for
committing the atrocity violating the human
rights of people where sick and the
disabled take refuge, and where
professionals are engaged in the most
humanitarian endeavor of looking after the
sick and injured.
The victims of the massacre included three
leading medical specialists at that time,
Dr.A.Sivapathasuntharam, Dr.K.Parimelalahar
and Dr.K.Ganesharatnam, three nurses and
fifteen other employees.
|
|
|