Tuesday March 31st
2009
8:30-9:30 Registration and Coffee
(Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
9:30- 11:15 Plenary Session - Chair: Professor John Darwin, University of
Oxford
(Old Theatre, Ground Floor, Old Building)
9:30-9:45 Welcome Address - Dr. John Hutchinson, LSE
9:45-10:15 Nationalism might change its character, again - Professor
John
Hall, McGill University
Abstract: Much classical theory about nationalism�including
that of Ernest Gellner, whose biography I have just completed--comes
from the experiences of a particular period of European history, roughly
speaking 1870-1945. It might be helpful, given the theme of this
conference, to ask at the start about the intensity of nationalism in
that period, in the light of more recent scholarship, so as then to
contrast it with contemporary circumstances. The paper will argue that
some things have changed, but that this has less to do with
globalization�which does have some importance�than with changing
geopolitical conditions.
10:15-10:45
Globalisation and Nationalism: Changing Proximities in the
Past - Professor Juergen Osterhammel, University of Konstanz
Abstract: The concepts of nationalism and globalisation cannot be
paired easily. They derive from different traditions in the social
sciences, embody different kinds of historical experience and are
usually expressed in distinct narratives. It is perhaps possible, but
not really convincing to fuse them into one unified story of the
globalisation of nationalism and the national conditioning of increasing
globality. Hardly more persuasive is the alternative view of nationalism
and globalisation as two contradictory principles locked in perpetual
antagonism.
The lecture will refrain from any totalising approach. It will try to
demonstrate that, over the past two centuries or so, nationalism and
globalisation sometimes grew close, intersected and reinforced one
another while at other times they drifted apart. Moreover, the evolution
of nationalism and the trajectory of globalisation are just two among
several general tendencies shaping the modern world. They should not be
seen in isolation.
10:45-11:15 Questions
11:15-11:45 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
11:45-13:15 Panel Session 1 (Connaught House, LSE)
Nationalism and Globalisation in Africa (H103)
Chair Mr. Chris Moffat, LSE
Dr. Michael Amoah -
Supranationalism, Globalisation and Africa
Ms. Tinenenji Banda -
The APRM Process: Schizophrenic Institutionalism Par
Excellence
Dr. Gabrielle Lynch - Kenya�s New Indigenes: Negotiating Local Nationalisms
in a Global Context
Diaspora Politics in Former Communist Europe (H105)
Chair Mr. Tobias Eule, University of Cambridge
Mr. Francesco Ragazzi -
Diaspora Politics as Globalized Ethnic Engineering:
The Case of Former Yugoslavia.
Dr. Ulrike Ziemer - Longing and Belonging: Armenians and Long Distance
Nationalism in Southern Russia
Dr. Irina Isaakyan -
Living in a trans-national social space: The case of
Russian academic Diaspora
Perceptions of the Nation in Art (H216)
Chair Ms. Rosanne Watson-Bangau, LSE
Prof. Huey-Rong Chen -
From Beethoven�s Symphony No. 7 to Taiwanese Film
"Cape No. 7": the "Realization" of Taiwanese Identity/Nationality through
Cultural Globalization/Localization
Dr. Andrea Kollnitz - International Influences - Danger or Liberation?
Internationalism and Nationalism in Early 20th century Art-criticism
Ms. Didem Turkoglu -
Facebook: Flagging the Turkish Nation in the Face
Youth Conceptions of Nationalism and Ethnicity (H202)
Chair TBA
Mr. Jeroen Moes - CosmoPoles: The European Identity of Higher Educated
Polish Youth in a Comparative Perspective
Mr. Tobias Eule -
Ethnicity in Practice: On the Construction of "Ethnic
Youth Gangs" in Germany
Dr. Natasha Warikoo -
Young Elite Conceptions of British Identity and
Immigrant Assimilation
13:30-14:30 Lunch
14:30-16:00 Panel Session 2 (Connaught House, LSE)
Nationalism and Migration in a Global Era (H103)
Chair Mr. Tobias Eule, University of Cambridge
Mr. Liav Orgad - Illiberal Liberalism: Cultural Restrictions on Migration
and Access to Citizenship in Europe
Mr. Jacques Lundja - Global migration patterns and national identities
Mr. Diego Acosta -
A Belief in the Purity of the Nation in Europe? Possible
Dangers of its Influence in Migration and Citizenship Legislation
Dr. Veronika Bajt -
When do I Belong? Transnational Migration and National
Identity
Local, Regional and National Perspectives of Globalisation (H105)
Chair Mr. Barak Levy-Shilat, LSE
Dr. Muriel Rambour -
Another "Third Way". Could post-nationalism overcome
the classical opposition between nationalism and supra-nationalism?
Prof. Sandra Halperin -
Nationalism Reconsidered: the Local/Trans-local
Nexus of Globalisation
Dr. Kees Terlouw -
Rescaling Identity: Communicating Regional Identity
Between National Identity and Global Competition
Theorising Nationalism and Globalisation (H216)
Panel sponsored by the Kuwait Programme on Development, Governance and
Globalisation in the Gulf States, LSE, Centre for the Study of Global Governance
Chair Mr. Iavor Rangelov, LSE Centre for the Study of Global Governance
Prof. Andre Liebich -
Globalizing the 'Principle of Nationality�
Dr. Gordana Uzelac -
Survival of the Fitter: The Process of National
Apperception
Dr. Steven Mock -
The End of Globalisation, The End of Nations
International Peacekeeping and Human Rights (H202)
Chair Dr. Esra Bulut, EU Institute for Security Studies
Dr. Rachel - Hutchins-Viroux - International NGOs and the Transformation of
Solidarity in the Global Age: The Evolution of Community Sentiment in the
United States
Dr. Asta Maskaliunaite Nationalism and the peacekeeping discourse.
Political and military viewpoints
Dr. Denisa Kostovicova
Dr. Vesna Bojicic-DzelilovicBosnia�s �octopus of crime�: Transnational
networks and post-conflict nationalism
Prof. Yamuna - Sangarasivam Extraordinary Rendition: Nationalism and
Globalization as Complementary Forces in the U.S. Sponsored "Global War on
Terror"
16:00-16:30 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
16:30-18:00 Panel Session 3 (Connaught House, LSE)
Beyond Multiculturalism? (H103)
Chair Ms. Farah Jamal, LSE
Dr. Ephraim Nimni Nationalism and the Globalisation of Multiculturalism
Dr. Mathieu Claveyrolas Mauritius: a quasi-India and a Creole nation
Extremism and Anti-Immigration (H105)
Chair Ms. Sofia Vasilopoulou, LSE
Dr. Chris Gilligan �[They] help perpetuate "they�re taking our jobs"
kinds of arguments�: attitudes towards immigrants in a divided society
Ms. Sofia Vasilopoulou/
Ms Nathalie Brack Euroscepticism in radical right parties: same stance,
different causality. A question of two different conceptions of national
identity?
Prof. Michel Huysseune Defending national identity and interests: the
asymmetrical model of globalisation of the Lega Nord
Dr. Djamel Mermat Identity withdrawal within the "planetary village:" a
comparison between the British National Party and French National Front in
the face of "globalization"
Novel Forms of Nationalism (H216)
Chair Ms Margit Wunsch, LSE
Prof. Nicole Gallant Pan-aboriginal movements and identity: a
multi-layered form of nationalism?
Mr. Jean-Paul Sarrazin New Discourses On National Identity And Ethnic
Minorities.
The influence of global trends in Colombia
Mr. Gabor Halmai Us Versus? Re-Imagining the Nation in Hungary and Brazil
Case Studies in Contemporary Diaspora nationalism (H202)
Chair Mr. Tobias Eule, University of Cambridge
Dr. Anne- Sophie Bentz Reconsidering National Identity in the Tibetan
Diaspora
Dr. Deepa Nair Diasporic Hindu nationalist discourse over representation
of
Hinduism in school texts in America
Dr. Luis Xavier
Rangel-Ortiz The Emergence of a New Form of Mexican Nationalism in San
Antonio, Texas
Dr. Sarah Keeler Globalisation, Identity and �Cosmopolitan Nationalism�
within Kurdish Diasporic Spaces
Wednesday April 1st
2009
9:30-11:00 Panel Session 4 (Connaught House, LSE)
Global Trends in Banal Nationalism (H103)
Chair Dr. John Hutchinson, LSE
Mr. Vincent Martigny �Cuisine Fran�aise� versus �Mc World�: The Politics
of Gastronomy as a Banal Nationalism�s Response to Globalisation in France
Dr. Helene Thiollet National identity and immigration in Saudi Arabia:
From exceptionalism to "banal nationalism"?
Mr. Etienne Smith Senegalese nationhood under global conditions:
homogeneisation and pluralisation of the Senegalese national identity?
Globalisation and Novel forms of Nationalism (H216)
Panel sponsored by the LSE Centre for the Study of Global Governance
Chair Mr. Iavor Rangelov, LSE Centre for the Study of Global Governance
Dr. Heinrich Matthee Globalization, a transformed political order and new
forms of Afrikaner nationalism, 1994-2009
Dr. Tigran Matosyan Does Europe Cause Nationalism? European Values and
Identity Construction In Modern Armenia
Dr. Agnieszka Joniak-L�thi Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (PRC) and
the Interaction between the National and the Global
Globalisation Before the Age of Nationalism (H105)
Chair Ms. Zeynep N. Kaya
Mr. Vasilis Molos Nationness in the Absence of a Nation: Narrating the
Prehistory of the Greek National Movement
Mr. Barak Levy-Shilat Diaspora politics in the 18th Century: The British
Intervention in Favour of the Jews of Bohemia
Dr. Michal Luczewski Imperial cosmopolitans. Galician peasants before
nations and nationalism
Global Economy and the Nation (H202)
Panel sponsored by the Global Public Policy Network and the Journal of Global
Policy
Chair Dr. Eva-Maria Nag, Executive Editor of Global Policy / Research Fellow
Centre for the Study of Global Governance, LSE
Dr. Jonathan Hearn Global crisis, national blame
Dr. Sam Pryke Economic crisis and nationalism
11:00-11:30 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
11:30-13:00 Plenary Session (Old Theatre, Ground Floor, Old Building)
Chair: Professor John Breuilly, LSE
11:30-12:00 Waves of Nationalism in the Tides of Globalisation:
Contrarian Conclusions Drawn From Southeast Asian History - Professor
John Sidel, LSE
Abstract: Against the prevailing tendency to see globalization
as a narrowly recent trend and nationalism as a phenomenon of much
earlier vintage, this paper resituates the rise of what are usually
understood as "nationalist movements" in Southeast Asia against the
backdrop of the longer history of the region's integration into broader
cultural, economic, intellectual, political, and sociological
circuitries of the world beyond. The rise of what is usually taken as
"nationalism," it is shown, unfolded in a setting that was profoundly
structured by the cosmopolitan legacies of successive waves of
integration within what scholars have termed 'the Sanskrit Cosmopolis',
the Indian Ocean 'interregional arena', and 'the Muslim world'. The
revolutions usually depicted as "nationalist," moreover, arose out of
the integration of Southeast Asia within the world capitalist economy
and the incorporation of Southeast Asians into distinctly transnational
intellectual and ideological currents and structures in the late 19th
and early-mid 20th centuries. As seen in the global nature of the
peregrinations and political connections of leading "nationalist"
figures, the prominent role of diasporic communities, and the key
opportunities opened up by international conflicts (e.g. major wars),
there was much in the making of "nationalism" that was transnational and
international. Against this backdrop, a revisionist history of Southeast
Asia leads to the conclusion that the winning of independence and the
making of new nation-states in the region represented not only the
success of nationalism but in crucial other ways the onset of
disappointment and failure.
12:00-12:30 Nationalism and the Politics of Culture in a Globalizing
World - Professor Stephanie Lawson, Macquarie University
Abstract: Debates surrounding the themes of nationalism,
globalization and culture over the last two decades or so have tended to
evoke a certain imagery � or at least two opposing sets of images, each
of which emanates from a certain thesis about where the world is heading
in terms of its essential structure. On the one hand, the globalist
thesis sees the breakdown of national boundaries � boundaries which have
been conceptualized not only in terms of the legal-institutional
structure of sovereign states but also in terms of social phenomena,
often expressed in the idea of �culture�. On the other hand, there are
numerous supporters of the notion that the world is likely to remain
structured predominantly around �nation-states� and that these entities
will not only continue as the most prominent actors in world politics
but will also remain the primary site of affective attachment for the
vast majority of the world�s people. These two basic positions are also
reflected in normative international theory, especially in the
communitarian/ cosmopolitan debates over the source of moral values as
well as how far moral responsibility extends. The concern of this paper
is not simply to sift through the various arguments supporting one
or other of these positions, but to bring into focus the question of how
culture has been conceptualized in these debates. I suggest that the
starting point for most debates on culture in world politics draws from
traditional anthropological ideas, the emergence of which are also
closely associated with nationalist thought. Conceptions of culture
based on these ideas have met with robust criticism from proponents of
universalist causes � causes which have become much more prominent in
the post-cold war period. This paper argues that both particularist and
universalist approaches have something to offer in the continuing
project of conceptualizing �culture� in a globalizing world which is,
nonetheless, likely to remain irredeemably pluralistic not along
�national� lines, but in numerous other ways as well.
12:30-13:00 Questions
13:00-14:30 Lunch Break
14:30- 16:00 Panel Session 5 (Connaught House, LSE)
Theoretical Perspectives of Territoriality and Transnationalism (H103)
Chair Professor John Breuilly, LSE
Dr. John Etherington Globalisation, Territoriality and Nationalism
Prof. Sarah Danielsson Pan-Nationalism Reframed: Theories of Nationalism,
the Role of the "Nation-State," and the Global Age
Mr. Torsten Weber "Asia for the Asians"? Japanese pan-Asianism between
nationalist chauvinism and �One World� utopia (1905-20)
Globalising Forces on Nationalism in the Early 20 th
Century (H105)
Chair Mr. Barak Levy-Shilat, LSE
Mr. Bj�rn Hofmeister Cultural Nationalism, Transnational Citizenship,
Colonialism. Geo-Political Visions and Social Mobilization of the Pan-German
League, 1891-1939
Prof. Matthew Plowman Nationalism as a Weapon in Global Conflict: The
Indo-Irish-German Conspiracy of World War I
Ms. Louise Bergstr�m Global migration and ethnic nationalism: Sweden in
the early 20th century
Sub-state Nationalism in the Middle East (H216)
Chair Dr. Vivian Ibrahim, SOAS
Ms. Alessandra Cecolin Has Zionism suffocated Iranian cultural identity?
The condition of Iranian Jewish immigrants in Israel between 1951 and 1979
Mr. Ibrahim Saylan Transformation of an Old Conflict? The Interplay of
Turkish Nationalism and Kurdish Sub-state Nationalism within European
Integration Process
The Impact Of Globalisation on National Identity in Europe (H202)
Chair Ms. Vanessa Spencer, LSE
Prof. Angel Rivero Internationalism and the Invention of the 1st of
December National Day in Portugal
Ms. Jula Doebner "You are Germany" � The reconstruction of German
national identity in a globalized world
Dr. Joanna Kaftan Elite strategies in a global world: A Typology of
Polish Patriots
Dr. Jose Sobral Immigration and contemporary definitions of Portuguese
national identity
16:00-16:30 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
16:30- 18:00 Round Table Discussion (Old Theatre, Ground Floor, Old Building)
Chair: Dr. Daphne Halikiopoulou, LSE
Professor Ronald Suny The Future of a Failure: Globalisation and the
Nation-State
Professor John Breuilly Nationalism as Global History
Dr. John Hutchinson Globalisation and Nation-formation in World History
Thursday April 2nd
2009
10:00-11:30 Panel Session 6 (Connaught House, LSE)
Reinventing Nationalism through European Integration (H103)
Chair TBA
Dr. Madalena - Meyer Resende Extroverted and introverted types of
nationalism and their responses to European integration: evidence from
Spanish and Polish right-wing political parties
Dr Jon Fox/ Dr. Peter Vermeersch Backdoor nationalism: EU accession and
the reinvention of nationalism in Hungary and Poland
Dr. Daniel Esparza-Ruiz National Identity and the Other in the Global
Era: The Czechs facing the EU
Mr. Alain- Marc Rieu The EU today: beyond pan-nationalism and
globalization
Language and Education between the National and the Global (H105)
Chair Mr. Robert Schertzer, LSE
Prof. Roman Szul The Politics of Language in Contemporary Europe: between
Nationalism, European Integration and Globalisation
Prof. George Richardson/ Mr Laurence Abbott Between the National and the
Global: Exploring Tensions in Canadian Citizenship Education
Dr. Tuba Kanci Reconfigurations of Turkish National Identity and
Nationalism in the Europeanization Process: An Analysis of Primary
Schoolbooks in Turkey
Ms. Kathleen Fincham Non-formal Education and the Construction of
Palestinian Identities in South Lebanon
Nationalism, Transnationalism and Justice (H216)
Chair Mr. Eric Woods
Prof. Atalia Omer The Globalization of Justice and the Transferability of
Protest
Dr. Adriano Cirulli Globalisation, Transnational Social Movements and
Radical Nationalism in Basque Country and Ireland
Dr. Esra Bulut Turkish Foreign Policy Between Nationalism, Populism and
Transnational Solidarity
Sport: Global or National? (H202)
Chair Dr Daphne Halikiopoulou, LSE
Prof. Radim Marada Transnational Nationalism: forms of nationalism in
globalized sport arenas
Mr. Chris Phillips Arab Banal Nationalism: Al-Jazeera and the flagging of
Arab identity during the 2008 Beijing Olympics
Mr. Tilman Turpin Holidays from history�: the 2006 FIFA World Cup and new
German patriotism?
11:30-12:00 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
12:00-13:30 Panel Session 7 (Connaught House, LSE)
The Media, Nationalism and Globalisation (H103)
Chair Dr. Athena Leoussi, University of Reading
Ms. Maria Kyriakidou Imagining ourselves beyond the nation? Exploring
cosmopolitanism in relation to mediated representations of distant suffering
Dr. Sabina Mihelj Bringing the Nation back in: Nationhood, Seriality, and
Global Communication
Dr. Michael Skey "Do you realise you're a foreigner, and we're not used
to them managing our national team?" Using national football reporting in
England to analyse competing articulations of identity in an era of
globalisation
Dr. V�clav �tětka Global media, nation-bound tastes? Audiovisual media
flows and cultural identities in Central and Eastern Europe
Pan-Nationalism and the Middle East (H105)
Chair Dr. Vivian Ibrahim, SOAS
Mr. Djene Rhys Bajalan Pan Kurdish nationalism: Theory or Praxis?
Ms. Jasmine Gani Differentiating nationalisms in the pan-Arab context
Ms. Zeynep N. Kaya Kurdistan: Aspirational Territory of pan-Kurdish
nationalism
The Nation in Political Thought (H216)
Chair Dr. John Edwards, St. Francis Xavier University
Dr. Uriel Abulof We, the People? The Rise and Fall of Popular Sovereignty
in Canadian Political Thought
Abstract: Focusing on "foundational political ethics," the underlying ideas and ideals
that provide for legitimacy, this paper asks if, and how, does Canadian
(postmodern) political thought challenge the modern model of legitimacy. This
paper aims at deciphering the nature of modern political legitimacy and
understanding the uniqueness of Canada in this respect. I argue that Canada
poses a normative challenge to the modern model of legitimacy (and its epitome,
"popular sovereignty"), by substituting it with new political ethics. By being
an exception to the rule, it serves to illustrate it. This purview thus provides
us with an important key to better understand both the modern and the postmodern
models of political legitimacy, and the impact of globalization on the ethics of
nationalism.
Mr. Arie Dubnov The Anti-Cosmopolitan Liberals: Isaiah Berlin and Jacob
Talmon and the dilemma of national identity
Dr. Shabnam Holliday Khatami�s Islamist-Iranian Discourse of National
Identity: A Discourse of Resistance
Historical Perspectives of Nationalism and Globalisation in North America
(H202)
Chair Ms. Danielle Bieber, LSE
Dr. Robert McLaughlin No Surrender: Orange-Canadian Unionists and
Northern Ireland, 1919-1925
Dr. Kenneth Weisbrode American Nationalists Confront the Old World,
1909-19
Prof. Don Doyle Mass Migration in the Age of Nationalism
Mr. David Prior The Internal Divisions and Global Visions of American
Nationalism after the Civil War
13:30-14:30 Lunch
14:30- 16:30 Plenary Session (Old Theatre, Ground Floor, Old Building)
Chair: Dr. John Hutchinson, LSE
14:30-15:00 Rescaling the Nation. State Transformation and the
Nationalities Question - Professor Michael Keating, European University
Institute
Abstract: The central question of nationality politics is the
relationship of state and nation. In the present era both state and
nation are undergoing important transformations. This both creates new
nationality conflicts, and provides new ways of dealing with them.
15:00-15:30
Migration and Citizenship in the Making of a Global Labour Market -
Professor Stephen Castles, University of Oxford
[Note by
tamilnation.org see
also
Globalization and International Migration - Video presentation]
Abstact: The central argument of this paper is that economic
restructuring in the global North since the 1970s has been linked to a
new international division of labour, in which workers are
differentiated not only on the basis of human capital (education and
qualifications) but also on criteria of race, ethnicity, gender, origins
and legal status. The racialisation of labour and the hierarchisation of
citizenship are central elements of the global labour market which
developed during the neo-liberal ascendency from the late 1970s to 2008.
Migration has always been a way in which people seek to improve their
livelihoods. Today, the mobility of labour and its differentiation into
specific categories has become the basis of a new transnational class
structure. People holding the �right� passports and qualifications enjoy
mobility rights which come close to global citizenship. People from the
South who lack formal skills can often only move irregularly, running
enormous risks. Such workers are effectively non-citizens, and their
exclusion from rights is justified through racialisation and gender
stereotypes.
Neo-liberal practices such as temporary and causal employment, chains
of sub-contracting and informalisation affect both native and migrant
workers. However, it is disadvantaged and vulnerable workers � migrant
women, irregular workers, ethnic and racial minorities � who get the
most precarious positions. But the deprivation of human and worker
rights is giving rise to new social movements, such as the strikes of
migrant workers in Dubai in 2006, the migrant rights demonstrations of
2006 in the USA, and the movements of youth of migrant background in
European cities. The global financial crisis of 2008 could be a turning
point, but the direction is not predetermined: it may lead to new forms
of exploitation of vulnerable groups, or to employment and migration
regimes based on equal citizenship and rights for all
15:30-16:00 Questions
16:00-16:30 Coffee Break (Shaw Library, 6 th
floor, Old Building)
16:30-18:00 Panel Session 8 (Connaught House, LSE)
The Impact of Globalisation on Britishness (H103)
Chair Dr. Daphne Halikiopoulou, LSE
Ms. Shanti Sumartojo National identity in the globalised city:
Britishness and the use of Trafalgar Square
Ms. Maria Cecire Medievalism, Popular Culture, and Identity Formation:
Nationalism in a Globalizing World
Professor Mike Savage/ Dr. David Wright/ Dr. Modesto Gayo-Cal
Cosmopolitanism and the cultural reach of the White British
Dr. Gabriella Elgenius Does homeland matter? Diaspora in Britain: setting
the scene
Nations without States and States without Nations (H105)
Chair Ms. Danielle Bieber, LSE
Dr. Jeremy Allouche The nation state confluence, globalisation and
conflict in �non-nation� states
Mr. Brieg Powel Promoting the Dragon: National Identity and the
Construction of Wales as an International Actor
Minorities and Diaspora Communities in the Mediterranean (H216)
Chair Mr. Barak Levy-Shilat, LSE
Mr. Francesco Cerasani Nationalism and minorities in the Mediterranean.
The impact of Barcelona Process on national issues
Mr. Giovanni Picker Everyday Nationalism as neo-Localism. The "Gypsy
problem" in Italy between migration and national contexts
Dr. Aidan McGarry Voice and Participation in the European Union:
Responding to the Italian Roma Crisis
Globalisation, Authenticity and National Inclusion in Asia (H202)
Chair TBA
Ms. Young Ju Rhee From Ethnically based to Strategic Cosmopolitans: South
Korean Citizenship Reforms since 1997
Dr. Sze Wei Ang Religion and Regionalism as Racial Supplements
Mr. Jaewoon Bang The Effects of Starbucks on Local Coffee Consumption
Culture: Case Study of South Korean Starbucks Patrons
Mr. Julian Manning Persistence of Identity in Japan
18:15-18:30 Closing Address (Old Theatre, Ground Floor, Old Building)
Prof. John Breuilly, LSE
PARTICIPANTS� ABSTRACTS
We, the People? The Rise and Fall of Popular Sovereignty in Canadian
Political Thought -
Dr Uriel Abulof , Princeton University
Focusing on "foundational political ethics," the underlying ideas and ideals
that provide for legitimacy, this paper asks if, and how, does Canadian
(postmodern) political thought challenge the modern model of legitimacy. This
paper aims at deciphering the nature of modern political legitimacy and
understanding the uniqueness of Canada in this respect. I argue that Canada
poses a normative challenge to the modern model of legitimacy (and its epitome,
"popular sovereignty"), by substituting it with new political ethics. By being
an exception to the rule, it serves to illustrate it. This purview thus provides
us with an important key to better understand both the modern and the postmodern
models of political legitimacy, and the impact of globalization on the ethics of
nationalism.
A Belief in the Purity of the Nation in Europe? Possible Dangers of its
Influence in Migration and Citizenship Legislation -
Mr Diego Acosta, King's College, London
Immigration is tremendously important in the EU. In order to address the
subject, Governments are constantly changing their migration and citizenship
laws and moreover increasingly linking them with integration requirements. Among
those requirements, there is a new emphasis on language acquisition and
knowledge of the country�s history. This is being applied not only to gain
citizenship but also in order to obtain permanent residence or as a precondition
for the arrival of family members.Why is this common trend taking place at this
particular point in time? It could be argued that these tests are a return to
strong nation-building. There is a constant repetition of the belief in the
purity of the nation in certain political discourses. This line of thinking
creates a worrying problem for the future as European national identities are
seen as immutable, thus complicating the integration of the new Europeans with
an immigrant background.This is not new. States and regimes used these two
elements in the 19th century to create nations. However, these processes
produced dangerous results of exclusion. Hence a question arises, are these
developments desirable in enhancing the integration of immigrants in Europe or
do they run the risk of increasing the possibilities of constructing a new
�Other�?
Supranationalism, Globalisation and Africa
-
Dr Michael Amoah, The Open University
The various forms of nationalism and their international dimensions produce
global contours which have security and economic implications for globalisation.
Nationalism as an expression of identity and competing interests could be
ethnonational, subnational, national, consociational, international,
transnational, multinational, or supranational, and subsequently manifest
politically as ethnonationalisms, nation-states, consociational states,
multinational states and supranationalisms, including supranationalisms with
linguistic and religious foundations yet with political, security and economic
implications, such as the Arab League and the Organisation of the Islamic
Conference. This presentation would argue that despite globalisation being a
process by which the people of the world are unified into a single society and
function together, and the advantages thereof, nationalism by its very nature,
operates against the aims of globalisation and ensures that there are always
identity and related interests separating the globe. The paper would discuss the
politics of supranationalisms, and their impact on globalised efforts at
resolving humanitarian crises, using the UN Security Council and Sudan as an
example.
Religion and Regionalism as Racial Supplements
-
Dr Sze Wei Ang, UCLA
Race continues to be over-determined by national contexts but as the growing
literature on transnationalism and globalization shows, racial identity and
racial politics are becoming imbricated with politics and ideas that are
circulating more globally. Among the most persuasive and prevalent of
contemporary global debates is the debate over religion and religious
identities. However, the question of race remains the fetishized object in
religious discourse and this paper will uncover the role race plays in the
invocations of religion or religious authority. This paper looks at the example
of how Islam becomes subsumed within racial discourse especially in within the
context of the nation-state of Malaysia and relates it to broader histories of
regionalism in South East Asia. I argue that Islam is not only appropriated to shape the nationalist
imaginary and thus regulates race relations, but religious discourse also opens
the nation up to the transnational imaginary, where the national and
transnational flows mutually deconstruct, negotiate, and recalibrate the other.
Finally, I will gesture toward the possibility of etiolating an ethics of
transnationalism that is produce in response to and, in relation with,
nationalist politics.
Pan Kurdish nationalism: Theory or Praxis?
-
Djene Rhys Bajalan, Istanbul Bilgi University
This paper seeks to examine the phenomenon of �Pan Kurdish nationalism�.
Simply put, Pan Kurdish Nationalism is a nationalism that desires to unite all
Kurds living with the boundaries of �Kurdistan� (the Kurdish Homeland) under the
roof of on single and unified state. The concept of a single Kurdish state was a
product of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire at the end of the Great War.
However, the subsequent division of the Kurdish population and the projected
Kurdish Homeland (Kurdistan) amongst Iraq, Syria Turkey and Iran has led to the
development of a multiplicity of Kurdish nationalist organisation operating with
the boundaries of existing states. Furthermore, these varieties of Kurdish
nationalism are the products the specific conditions within Iran, Iraq, Turkey
and Syria and have often conflicted with each other to the determent of the Pan
Kurdish Dream. As such, it will be argued is that, as with Pan Arabism or pan
Turkism, Pan Kurdish nationalism although a powerful intellectual idea has in
fact found very little political expression.
When do I Belong? Transnational Migration and National Identity
-
Dr Veronika Bajt, Peace Institute, Institute for Contemporary Social and Political Studies,
Slovenia
Rethinking nationalism and national identity in the framework of
globalisation and transnational migration patterns, this paper tackles the
complex relationship between formal definitions of integration as a two-way
process and integration bills that remain embedded in centrality of national
identity as constructed by national states. It is necessary to study
globalisation and migration processes in conjunction with nationalism,
especially in order to understand xenophobic attitudes and anti-immigrant
prejudice. I argue for a more inclusive perspective that allows for
accommodation of transnational realities of migrants. Their experiences with
ethnic prejudice and discrimination speak of the need to confront the
exclusionary practices of national states. Though experiencing erosion of their
sovereignty that has accelerated with processes of globalisation, which diffuses
participation to sub-state and international levels, national states remain in
strong control over the question of "who belongs" and who is consigned to the
position of the "foreigner". It is for this reason that even obtaining
citizenship and thus formally becoming a "national" does not preclude one from
life on the margins, forever feeling like an "outsider". Using new empirical
material, I theorise gaps in nationalism research by exploring transnational
migrants� broader perspectives of identity, belonging and transnational ties.
The APRM Process: Schizophrenic Institutionalism Par Excellence
- Ms Tinenenji Banda, Regional Human Security Centre
The decline of the African nationalist movement and the advent of
globalisation and its supra-national institutional arrangements have left the
African intellectual agenda with a distinctive lacuna. The African Peer Review
Mechanism (APRM) with its reformist agenda and "new dawn" terminology is a
dexterous and ambitious attempt to reorganize the continents political and
economic firmament, and to assert the continents relevance in an integrating and
increasingly trans-national world economy. The fanfare and optimism that
characterized its incipience notwithstanding, the APRM faces an acute crisis
even as its minutiae are penned. In this paper I contend that the APRM and its
processes graphically depict the schizophrenic dilemma faced by supra-national
African institutions crafted to respond to the integrationist requirements of
transnationalism. I argue that because the APRM process is couched comfortably
within the neo-patrimonial arrangements that exclude a participatory and
consultative framework, it is therefore alienated from the grassroots
participation that has previously been necessary to ferment reform and shift
political firmaments. Consequently, despite its supra-national application and
its claim to international censure, its exclusionary and technocratic design
ensures that it exists only as a veneer of reform designed perhaps to
manufacture democracy rather than to enable it.
Reconsidering National Identity in the Tibetan Diaspora
-
Ms Anne-Sophie Bentz, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies
A diaspora is defined, at its simplest, as the dispersal of a people from an
original homeland. I would like to argue here that this defining feature remains
problematic for the Tibetan diaspora: Tibetan refugees, who have not dispersed much, or far, as the favourite destinations for refuge have been
Tibet�s neighbouring countries, i.e. India, Nepal and Bhutan, are still not
showing clear signs of wanting to disperse further, quite on the contrary. They
have indeed come to believe that the Tibetan national identity would be severely
threatened, should any further dispersion occur. I will illustrate this belief
with two examples, i.e. 1) the Tibetan refugees� mitigated reactions towards the
Tibetan United States Resettlement Project (TUSRP), and 2) the Tibetan refugees�
adherence to their refugee identity, and so to a precarious stateless statute,
especially in India. Yet, their resistance against the current trend of
globalisation, understood here as including migration, seems to be
simultaneously counterbalanced by a new willingness on their part to use at
least some of the resources available in an increasingly globalised world, such
as the improved means of communication, to create a kind of virtual Tibetan
diaspora, whose specific features I also intend to examine here in further
detail.
Global migration and ethnic nationalism: Sweden in the early 20th century
- Ms Louise Bergstr�m, European University Institute
This paper concerns the specific trajectory of "ethnic" nationalism that
developed in Sweden at the turn of the last century as a consequence of
migration on an increasingly global scale. In the decades around 1900 the
Swedish national was gradually constructed around ethnicity, race and racial
difference. Whereas this development primarily has been interpreted as the
outcome of factors internal to Sweden, it also needs to be read against the
background of global patterns of migration. Between 1860 and 1920 one million
Swedes emigrated, at the same time as immigration brought about an influx of
people to the country. In the resulting encounters with other cultures and
peoples, Swedish agents increasingly based the national on ethnicity and blood
lineage in a perceived practical and political need to identify who was
"properly" Swedish. This process of boundary drawing around the "ethnically"
Swedish national in the face of global migration is the focus of this paper.
Turkish Foreign Policy Between Nationalism, Populism and Transnational
Solidarity
- Dr Esra Bulut, EU Institute for Security Studies
The paper explores nationalist and populist language used to communicate, and
communicated by, foreign policy by elected leaders in Turkey. It also
investigates a recurrent practice of combining nationalist and populist themes,
arguments and imagery with appeals to transnational solidarity and justice in
the course of this policy. It is often suggested that this language serves the
function of dressing up policy based on geopolitical considerations to make it
more palatable to electors and others. The paper challenges this reading,
suggesting a more holistic approach to the politics of foreign policy. The paper
explores three sets of questions relating to content, context and impact. First,
why and how do nationalist and populist themes, arguments and imagery occur in
Turkish foreign policy? Second, when and how are references to nationalism and
populism combined with appeals to transnational solidarity and justice? When and
why are particular combinations historically and politically possible? Third,
when and how does this language �cascade� into international politics? The paper
analyses the current policy towards the Arab-Israeli Conflict to this effect.
The findings from this case are contextualized with an examination of earlier
periods. The implications for our understanding of Turkish foreign policy and
politics are explored.
Medievalism, Popular Culture, and Identity Formation: Nationalism in a
Globalizing World
- Ms Maria Cecire, University of Oxford
From questions of "natural" class structure to the rights and abilities of
women to the characterization of Islamic societies, children�s fantasy has used
medieval voices to negotiate the kinds of "timeless" truths that govern
attitudes and behaviours in present-day Britain and its cultural offshoots.
These concepts have been widely spread via a variety of media, profoundly
impacting how young people�s individual identities and, consequently, their
national identities develop all over the world. This paper establishes the
historical and political foundations of children�s fantasy, which is largely
based on nostalgic reimaginings of a heroic Anglicised past. It goes on to
consider the wider ramifications of fantasy for young people as a potent global
export as we approach a future in which the Harry Potter generation must take
the lead on finding solutions for an array of pressing international issues. By
interrogating some of the ways in which children�s fantasy has reworked and
represented medieval narratives, characters, and concepts, this paper will serve
as an introduction to thinking about what role medievalisms play in popular
children�s literature and, as a result, how they manifest themselves as a
potentially nationalist sentiment in contemporary society.
Has Zionism suffocated Iranian cultural identity? The condition of Iranian Jewish immigrants in Israel between 1951 and 1979
- Ms Alessandra Cecolin, SOAS
This paper attempts to analyse why and how the conflict between nationality
(Zionism) and Iranian cultural identity became an increasingly difficult issue
for the Iranian Jews who decided to immigrate to Israel in 1948, and again after
the Khomeini Revolution in 1979. The central aim of this paper is to investigate
the relationship between nationalistic and cultural identity through a
comparison of these two Iranian Jewish migrations to Israel and determine if
during these two different historical periods each with own peculiar
socio-political circumstances, Zionism precipitated the suffocation of Iranian
cultural identity by absorbing Iranian Jewry into the Israeli mainstream. The
two periods of history under examination, 1948 and 1979, were both meaningful
and defining moments in Iranian Jewish history: the birth of Israel in 1948 gave
Diaspora Jews the first opportunity to become citizens of an Israeli State
whilst the Khomeini Revolution in 1979, nominally identified Iran as an Islamic
State and it officially denied any relations with Israel. These two Iranian
Jewish migrations to Israel in 1948 and 1979 impacted upon the cultural
differences between Iranian Jews and Israelis. While the first Iranian
immigrants in 1948 dealt with more cultural difficulties when they settled in
Israel, the latter had to cope with Khomeini�s anti-Zionist policy and more
volatile international relations between the two states. The differing
circumstances under which the two Iranian Jewish migrations occurred directly
influenced the extent to which cultural identity was protected amongst the
Iranian diaspora in the face of rising nationalism.
Nationalism and minorities in the Mediterranean. The impact of Barcelona Process on national issues
-
Mr Francesco Cerasani, University of Rome �La Sapienza�
The wider Mediterranean region is a space of intensive social exchanges and
of high symbolical significance with regard to the issues of nationalism. Once a
borderland, the Mediterranean is nowadays a boundary of deep tensions. The
Mediterranean traverses multiple national, religious, socio-cultural and
economic dividing lines. Cross-border ethnic groups, minorities and a wide
spectrum of religious communities coexist with global phenomena, such as the
impact of migration. In the last 15 years the EU, through the Euro-Mediterranean
partnership and the European Neighbourhood Policy, started an action in the
Mediterranean region aimed at giving a comprehensive and unifying response to
this divide. The EU developed a new framework of mutual obligations in the field
of human rights, with a particular focus on minority issues, and promoted
projects of political and functional regional integration. The outcome of the
commitment of the EU with its southern partners is still controversial. The
regional integration hasn't moved forward and old conflicts around the
Mediterranean are still open. However, recent evolutions and reforms in some
Southern partners suggest a positive link with regard to minority rights,
democratisation and conflict resolution.
From Beethoven�s Symphony No. 7 to Taiwanese Film "Cape No. 7": the
"Realization" of Taiwanese Identity/Nationality through Cultural
Globalization/Localization -
Professor Huey-Rong Chen, Department of Journalism, Culture University, Taipei, Taiwan
Through semio-narrative analysis of two classical music pieces in two popular
media texts in Taiwan: Beethoven�s Symphony No. 7 in the Japanese drama Nodame
Cantabile (2006) and Schubert�s "Heather Rose" in the Taiwan�s second top
grossing film Cape No. 7 (2008), this paper argues that Taiwan�s multi-ethnic
national identity has to be "realized" through its own cultural production, not
simply consumption, under the awareness of both the situation and the
availability of cultural globalization. The "articulation" that Stuart Hall once
applied to audience studies can be found in this paper that a market successful
cultural work is because the production of the local is able to "utter clearly"
from its specific social/historical perspective, then "form the joint" with the
global theme. However, this identity "articulation" and "realization" has been
operated under the market logic of global cultural flow, which, while maintains
the availability of globalization for the local, contains a danger to confine
the local�s view of the global and thus risks a simple ideological utterance if
the creator does not aware of the other dimensions of cultural
globalization/localization. In Taiwan�s case, it is the examination and
exploration of its own globalization process in both history and everyday life
that consequently comprises, then "realizes" its own multi-ethnic and
multi-cultural nationality that signifies the future integration that must
across ethnic, even national boundaries.
Globalisation, Transnational Social Movements and Radical Nationalism in Basque Country and Ireland
-
Dr Adriano Cirulli, University of Rome �La Sapienza�
Social movements emerged historically within nation-states. As actors of
mobilisations they have claimed against the state, considering it as the main
polity and the main target of protests. Due to globalisation, and the consequent
processes of political and economical transnationalisation (multinational
corporations; multilevel governance; increasing role of NGOs; development of
supranational institutions such as the European Union), social movements are
transforming their strategy and their forms of action. The clearest example of
this trend is represented by the emergence, mainly in the last decade, of a
transnational network that several leading social movements scholars call
�Global Justice Movement� (GJM). The main hypothesis at the base of the paper is
that the transnationalisation of social movements and protests is reshaping also
stateless nationalist movements, and particularly radical nationalisms that
since the 1960s have developed a leftist discourse and strategy, mixing national
liberation and revolutionary socialism. Grounding on some key concepts and
methods developed in social movements and nationalism studies (framing
processes; repertoires of action; nationalism as thin ideology; etc.), the paper
intends to analyse if and how the transnationalisation of protest and the
emergence of GJM are transforming Basque and Irish radical nationalist
movements� ideology and strategy.
Mauritius: a quasi-India and a creole nation
-
Dr Mathieu Claveyrolas, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (Paris, France)
My paper deals with the Mauritius historical and contemporary context, from
my anthropological point of view. The ongoing construction of a nation in a
context of creoleness (dynamic interpenetration of various cultures resulting
from forced migration and slavery context) seems highly relevant for
understanding the articulation of globalisation and nationalism. In 150 years,
the Indo-Mauritians (mostly Hindus ; now 60% of the total population) passed
from a quasi-enslaved minority to a majority leading the construction of this
new nation. I will discuss, first, the creole nation as the very experience (or
prefiguration, as often stated) of globalisation. Then, I will analyse the
ambiguous relation of Indo-mauritians to the creole nation. I will also try to
contextualise and focus on the changes over time. From a "re-incarnated"
indianity (from India to Mauritius) to a "renewed" identity (in the
globalisation context), many possible futures can be assessed : will Mauritius
illustrate the creole capacity of merging various identities ? Will it incarnate
a modern Indian diasporic identity ? While creoleness, inventing supranational
identities, challenges classical nationalism, can we nonetheless dismiss the
possibility for the new nation to eventually foster traditional national bonds ?
Pan-Nationalism Reframed: Theories of Nationalism, the Role of the "Nation-State," and the Global Age
-
Dr. Sarah K. Danielsson, City University of New York
This theoretical/historical paper argues that historians need to reevaluate
the relationship between the "nation-state" and nationalism. Questioning the
wide range of theoretical work on nationalism, this paper argues that
pan-Nationalism needs to be reexamined and placed more prominently within the
discussion of nationalism. Using specific examples of pan-Slavism,
pan-Germanism, pan-Arabism, and pan-Turkism, from the 1860s to the 1920s this
paper shows that:
1) pan-Nationalism did not rely on the "nation-state" but on
the "racialized nation," beyond borders and frontiers;
2) the principles of
pan-Nationalism extended beyond the official movements and permeated other,
often more accepted, forms of nationalism;
3) pan-Nationalism was not just an
"eastern" development, but, contrary to much theoretical work on nationalism,
permeated also so-called "western" nationalisms (comparative evidence from
England, France and the United States � such as Manifest Destiny- will be used
to prove this point);
4) It was the strength of the pan-Nationalist arguments,
and their broad acceptance in national debates, that allowed nationalism to
flourish later in a globalized age � contrary to what constructionists have
argued would take place.
This paper concludes that our present theories of
nationalism should be refocused from the historically flawed reliance on the
"nation-state" and sovereignty. The paper argues that both modern and
post-modern strains of nationalism were ripe for the globalized world because of
the rise of pan-Nationalism and its influence on the concept of "nation."
"You are Germany" � The reconstruction of German national identity in a
globalized world -
Ms Jula Doebner, London School of Economics and Political Science
Through discourse and visual analysis the study explores how German national
identity is reconstructed in a globalized world, using the social-marketing
campaign "Du bist Deutschland" ("You are Germany") as a case study.
Theoretically built upon the notions of collective memory, othering and
stereotyping the present analysis seeks to understand how the reconstruction of
Germanness produced through the campaign deals with an increased globalized and
diverse society and how this interacts with the specific German historical
memory. Understanding nations as imagined communities and "systems of cultural
representations" (Hall 1994:200) this analysis focuses on the discursive construction of national sameness and
difference. Therefore the narrative of a collective political history, the
discursive construction of a common culture and the discursive construction of a
�national body� have been adopted from Wodak et al (1999) as discursive
formations and will be used as guiding analytical themes. Highlighting thus the
unifying and divisive power of national identity this study demonstrates the
elitist nature of the campaign, as certain historical elements, places and
people are established as the �others� within it. Providing a wider conception
of national identity this study contributes to the understanding of �our�
(Western) nationalism and how nations deal with difference in a global age.
Mass Migration in the Age of Nationalism
-
Professor Don H Doyle, McCausland Professor of History, University of South Carolina
The rise of nationalism in Europe and the Americas between the Napoleonic
wars and World War I coincided with the largest mass migration in human history.
Precisely as nationalism was supposed to intensify popular identification with
the homeland, millions of citizens were choosing to reassign their national
identity. Between 1815 and 1930, 54 million Europeans migrated to the Americas,
33 million of them to the USA. That so many came out of the same
places--Ireland, Germany, Italy, Poland, and other parts of Europe--where
nationalism stirred the masses underscores this intriguing yet strangely
neglected paradox. This paper proposes some new ways of understanding how
nationalism and international migration interacted.
The Anti-Cosmopolitan Liberals: Isaiah Berlin and Jacob Talmon and the dilemma of national identity
-
Mr Arie Dubnov, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The debate between contemporary cosmopolitans and scholars of nationalism is
hardly new. A similar dilemma lurked in the shadows of the writings of many of
the founding fathers of the study of nationalism, and especially the Jewish
�migr�s among them, such as Hans Kohn, Ernest Gellner and Elie Kedourie. In this
lecture I will focus on two other postwar Jewish Anglophile intellectuals who
took part in this debate � the Oxonian liberal philosopher Sir Isaiah Berlin and
the Israeli historian Jacob Talmon. I divide my discussion into three: First I
will examine Berlin and Talmon's position within the postwar anti-totalitarian
discourse and what came to be known as as "liberalism of fear". Secondly, I will
show how Jewish identity, combined with deep Zionist convictions, pushed both to
divorce anti-nationalist cosmopolitanism, which they regarded as hollow
illusionary ideal and associated with impossible assimilation yearnings, from
the liberal idea. In conclusion I will suggest that although neither of them had
ever developed a systematic theoretical framework to deal with the complex
interactions between ethno-nationalism, liberal individualism and
multiculturalism, Berlin's vision of pluralism provides the foundations for
building such a theory, in which liberalism and nationalism become complementary
rather than conflicting notions.
Does homeland matter? Diaspora in Britain: setting the scene
-
Dr Gabriella Elgenius, Nuffield College and Department of Sociology, University of Oxford
The overall aim of this paper is to link understandings of �homeland� to
perceptions of �Britishness� and to explore ways in which Diaspora groups in
Britain seek to maintain and/or change their identities. We will investigate the
background and the setting for this project that is to be carried out within the
Polish and the Sikh communities in Britain with reference to notions of
belonging and identity expressed through ceremonies, celebrations and
commemorations. Through an understanding of the ceremonial forms we gain
insights into the nature of Diasporic community building projects and notions of
�home�. By comparing the Polish and the Sikh communities perceived �difference�
in terms of ethnicity, religion and �race� can also be identified. In this
context, the response of the dominant culture and the extent to which Diaspora
communities feel included into British culture may also be assessed. This
research has drawn upon previous findings conducted on nation building and
ceremonial change (Elgenius, 2005, 2008), the decline of traditional identities
(with Heath et al. 2007, 2009) and has received funding from the ESRC, the
British Academy and the John Fell Foundation.
National Identity and the Other in the Global Era: The Czechs facing the EU
- Dr Daniel Esparza-Ruiz, Palack� University in Olomouc
The increasing interest in national identity, especially from the 90s, is
closely related to the �general obsession� in the studies about identities
(personal and collective) that seem to be a symptom of the Zeitgeist, precisely
and paradoxically, when the spirit of the current time is dominated by a crisis
of identity, or a generalised crisis of identities, understood as a reaction to
human disorientation generated by the �digital revolution� and the expansion of
the internet, which have produced a drastic change in the relationship between
the human being and the past concept of time and space. In this context new
scenarios have emerged: globalisation and cyberspace. Identity is constructed
through successive identifications with significant Others, similarly, I
understand the EU enlargement and the process of �europeanisation� in
East-Central Europe as a symptom of Globalisation, and the EU the most
significant Other of today for the Czech national identity. In this sense, I
shall explore the influence of the EU in the Czech contemporary national
identity based on the following sources: i) the presidential speeches of Havel
and Klaus; ii) the electoral programmes of the main Czech political parties;
and, iii) the Czech public.
Globalisation, Territoriality and Nationalism
-
Dr John Etherington, Universitat Aut�noma de Barcelona (UAB)
Globalisation is usually understood, however implicitly, to operate according
to a deterritorialising logic that undermines the specific spatial configuration
of power and identity proposed by nationalism. While at a general, abstract
level, this position is probably correct, this paper argues that we must go
beyond a crude opposition between globalisation and nationalism, and develop an
approach capable of fully understanding the complex interrelationship between
these phenomena. In this respect, the paper argues that, from an empirical point
of view, historically states themselves have played an important role in the
global expansion of capitalism, while, in the contemporary world nation-states
continue to be both relevant actors and the focus of political mobilisation,
suggesting that we should not overstate the scope and scale of current
globalisation. From a theoretical perspective, although deterritorialisation is
key to understanding globalisation, territory can never be completely overcome:
deterritorialisation must necessarily be accompanied by the process of
reterritorialisation. Consequently, rather than reifying globalisation and
nationalism as somehow �out there� phenomena that operate independently of each
other and of society as a whole, we should stress that they are interrelated
processes that come together in specific spatial and historical contexts.
Ethnicity in Practice: On the Construction of "Ethnic Youth Gangs" in Germany
- Mr Tobias Eule, University of Cambridge
Based on ethnographic research into the identities of ethnic youth gangs in
Germany, this paper will point to the limitations of presupposing ethnic groups
to be both homogeneous and stable. Group deviance and criminality have spurred
heated debate and political campaigns in contemporary Germany. Often, these
issues are framed as referring to certain ethnic groups rather than young people
in general. By examining the composition and practice of youth gangs in a small
German town supposedly dominated by ethnic conflict between Russian and Turkish
youth gangs, my paper will argue that while the groups were organised around
ethnic categories, theses labels did not relate to the actual nationality or
ethnic background of the group members. Based on fieldwork carried out in the
Summer of 2007, the stark discrepancy between group labels and individual ethnic
background will be shown. This paper will argue that ethnicity is a structuring
resource for both the group and external labelling authorities, but rather a
cultural tool than based on a shared heritage. The paper will portray the
construction of these groups through practices of "becoming" an ethnic Turk or
Russian as well as the irrelevance of a shared national origin even when it
existed.
Non-formal Education and the Construction of Palestinian Identities in South
Lebanon
- Ms Kathleen Fincham, University of Sussex
The construction and regulation of �the nation� is both a goal and an outcome
of official state engineering. Through state institutions, such as the school,
the nation is constructed through the invention and use of a �national
literature�, a common national language, a common culture, a shared sense of
history and destiny, and a common set of expectations and behaviours rooted in a
sense of civic loyalty. However, in the absence of a state and its institutions,
Palestinians, particularly those in exile, must work to construct national
identity through other supranational and sub-national institutions. Through
empirical data gleaned from an ethnographic case study among Palestinian
refugees in south Lebanon, this presentation will examine how Palestinian youth
are constructing their identities through non-state institutions in Palestinian
society and through the processes of international labour migration. It will be
argued that, despite some limited benefits, this has ultimately led to the
construction of new Palestinian identities which are dangerously fragmented,
exclusive, conflicting and unregulated. Moreover, these identities have had real
social and material consequences for Palestinians in Lebanon.
Backdoor nationalism: EU accession and the reinvention of nationalism in Hungary and Poland
-
Dr Jon Fox, University of Bristol , Professor Peter Vermeersch, University of Leuven
The recent accession of eight East European countries to the European Union
in 2004 did not sound the death knoll of nationalism; rather, it signalled its
reinvention and, in some respects, reinvigoration. In this paper, we consider
three ways nationalism is accommodating itself in Hungary and Poland. First we
examine the reconfiguration of the left-right political spectrum along an axis
of national(ist) versus non-national(ist). Consensus on the desirability of
European unification has diminished the importance of traditional left-right
party identifications. In their place, the 'nation' has emerged as a convenient
fulcrum for inter-party contestation. Second, we examine how EU integration has
provided nationalists with a 'backdoor' for realising old nationalist ambitions
- albeit in a postmodern way. This isn't national reunification through
territorial revision, but rather symbolic reunification across the porous
borders of the EU's newest member states. In the third part of our paper we turn
to the emergence and strengthening of radical nationalist organisations outside
of the political establishment. It is our contention that the taming of
mainstream nationalism is related to the unleashing of these more virulent forms
of nationalism. Together, these three developments signal important changes in
the trajectory of nationalism in Hungary and Poland.
Pan-aboriginal movements and identity: a multi-layered form of nationalism?
-
Professor Nicole Gallant, INRS-Urbanisation Culture Soci�t�
The 1960s have seen the rise of pan-Indian movements, which were shaped by
local struggles for power. As globalization increases, more indigenous groups
are circumventing national politics and using international pressures to attempt
to obtain self-government powers.The foundations for unity (shared historical
experience; being perceived as a single unit by outsiders; an ideology of
indianness) are often strategically developed by native federations as part of a
nation-building process (Norman 2006), but they can also apply at the individual
level, when subjects are asked to define their aboriginal identities. Thus,
pan-aboriginal movements foster ties of solidarity that are stronger than those
towards human beings in general (Miller 1995; Smith 1991).However,
pan-aboriginal movements do lack some of the major characteristics most often
associated with nationalism, most importantly the quest for "self-determination"
(Gellner 1983; Ignatieff 1993; etc.). Although most entities within
pan-aboriginal movements do seek self-government for themselves, the political
units that are sought are not congruent with the pan-aboriginal national entity.
Drawing on discourse analysis of pan-aboriginal associations and on 41
qualitative interviews with aboriginal youth in Quebec, I argue that
pan-aboriginal movements may be interpreted as a form of multi-level
nationalism.
Differentiating nationalisms in the pan-Arab context
-
Ms Jasmine Gani , London School of Economics
As with all such ideologies, nationalism is not static; it is prone to
fluctuations, alterations and evolution, being contingent on varying
socio-political circumstances � thus the division between what constitutes
�cultural� and �political� nationalism can often be blurred. However,
notwithstanding this ongoing debate, I argue that nationalism at inter-state
levels are political ventures. Thus Arab nationalism is most potent and has had
the most success (limited though that has been) via the political route.
Although it has spawned cultural romanticism and a positive self-standing
identity in the intellectual field, its practical expression, particularly in
relation to popular opinion, has been as a political project juxtaposed against
an oppositional force. I also propose that, while Arab nationalism falls within
the basic rubric of nationalism, viewing it through a Eurocentric lens fails to
take account of its particularities in terms of its core principles, its
historical development and political manifestation. By paying greater attention
to the central notion of anti-colonialism in Arab nationalism, I argue that it
has continued relevance in the current regional context of military intervention
and globalisation, albeit having to negotiate its primacy with Islamism as a
fellow anti-imperialist pan-movement on the one hand, and statist nationalism as
a negating influence on the other.
�[They] help perpetuate "they�re taking our jobs" kinds of arguments�:
attitudes towards immigrants in a divided society
- Dr Chris Gilligan, University of the West of Scotland
Since 2003 there has been a significant growth in immigration to Northern
Ireland, a region of the United Kingdom previously characterised by net outward
migration. This shift to net inward migration took place after the signing of a
peace Agreement negotiated between representatives from Irish Nationalist and
Ulster Unionist parties and the British and Irish Governments. Despite the Agreement Northern
Ireland has continued to be characterised by a major social cleavage between
Catholics/Irish nationalists and Protestants/Ulster unionists. There are, for
example, a range of issues on which public opinion is significantly divided
along Nationalist/Unionist lines. Immigration is one such issue.�[They] help
perpetuate "they�re taking our jobs" kinds of arguments� (Sinn F�in local
councillor, interviewed 3rd December 2007). The quote can be read as an
anti-racist concern with the effects of the articulation of anti-immigration
views by Unionist politicians in Northern Ireland. The quote can also be read as
a sectarian articulation of the superiority of a cosmopolitan Irish nationalism
against exclusivist Ulster Unionist nationalism. This paper explores the
difference in attitudes between Irish Nationalists and Ulster Unionists and in
the wider context of the �divided society� that Northern Ireland continues to
be.The paper draws on original empirical research that we have carried out. This
research consisted of: a review of party manifestos; a survey of elected
representatives, and; interviews with elected representatives. The paper also
draws on surveys of the general public in Northern Ireland that we have been
involved in conducting.
Us Versus? Re-Imagining the Nation in Hungary and Brazil
-
Mr Gabor Halmai, Central European University
This paper uses a comparative framework to investigate how globalization has
engendered new types of nationalist movements as well as on how these new
imagined communities use and reflect on global events and networks. The
Hungarian "civic circles" have challenged the "Socialist" government�s
neoliberal restructuring with nostalgia for state socialism�s security alongside
pre-war nationalist imageries. The "national side" often equates itself with the
group of alleged "losers of transition". Overtly rightwing conservative agendas
thus merge with statist protectionist economic policy initiatives to result in
"rightwing populism" with national � yet deeply divisive � symbols remaining
central to the movement. The Brazilian MST, conversely, has traditionally
employed an explicitly socialist ideology dividing the nation along class
distinctions. However, the latest phase of Brazilian dependence on global
markets turned traditional class boundaries more blurred as racial and ethnic
terms enter the vocabulary of movement activists: Brazilian "people" thus
becomes a unifying national symbol to bring about the broadest coalition in an
effort to protect the country and its sovereignty.
Nationalism Reconsidered: the Local/Trans-local Nexus of Globalisation
- Professor Sandra Halperin, Royal Holloway, University of London
This paper elaborates a number of inter-related arguments concerning the
theoretical and historical relationship between globalisation and nationalism.
Its overall argument is that the emergence and generalisation of the
nation-state model was a product of an earlier phase of globalisation and,
specifically, of a dualistic process of expansion that, throughout the world,
worked to increase the cultural distance between cities and their surrounding
hinterlands. Capitalist development was from the start essentially
trans-national in nature and global in scope involving, not whole societies, but
the advanced sectors of dualistic economies in Europe, Latin America, Asia, and
elsewhere. The changes that unfolded with the emergence of capitalism proceeded,
not across broad national fronts (not through the expansion and integration of
national societies and economies) but along networks that linked export sectors
to each other. This dualism had, from the start as today, a simultaneous
globalising and localising dynamic. It linked together the upper strata of
communities around the world in a trans-local system of trade and inter-cultural
exchange; but, by restricting access to the material and cultural products
generated by this system, it simultaneously reinforced a separate set of rules,
processes, and conditions of life for the wider local population. It was in the
context of both the mobilisation and greater mobility of mass labour forces, and
the increasingly different systems for trans-local and local interests and
actors that the national idea emerged as a means of providing a new cultural
framework and basis for social cohesion and order.
Global Crisis, National Blame
- Dr Jonathan Hearn, University of Edinburgh
The current global financial-economic crisis offers a diagnostic opportunity
to explore the process of legitimation in the modern nation-state. Below the
globalisation of financial markets, at the heart of this crisis lies a
specifically national dynamic of legitimation, particular to affluent capitalist
liberal democracies. As Gellner noted in Thought and Change (1964), the
legitimacy of modern nation-states rests not just on rulers and ruled being
�co-nationals�, but also on their ability to deliver prosperity and economic
growth to their people. Collective pursuit of the power of wealth has both
shaped national identities, and helped drive the current crisis. Focusing on the
UK and the US, the paper presents a general model of the dynamics of
legitimation in such societies, involving patterns of interdependence and moral
assessment, between the state, economic agents, and the citizenry. It argues that this underlying structure of legitimation is reflected in
patterns of �social blaming� associated with the crisis. Amid politicians
accusing bankers of incompetence and irresponsibility, bankers accusing
politicians of incentivising unwise economic strategies, and more diffuse
critiques of a culture of credit among consumer-citizens, the basic dynamics of
national aspiration, now turned sour, are revealed.
Cultural Nationalism, Transnational Citizenship, Colonialism. Geo-Political
Visions and Social Mobilization of the Pan-German League, 1891-1939 -
Mr Bj�rn Hofmeister, Georgetown University
It has been argued recently that the period between 1880 and 1914 counts as
the high time of globalized communication and economic exchange that challenged
the classical nation-state and to which Germany responded with exclusive
nationalism. Taking the Pan-German League as the most influential nationalist
extra-parliamentary association, this observation lays the foundation for an
analysis of the relationship between global migration, transnational
citizenship, economic autarky, and ethnic nationalism in the strife of the
Pan-Germans for an expanding Germany in Central Europe and as a colonial Empire.
Growing out of a rising colonial movement of the 1880s, Pan-Germans were
concerned with the limited territorial extent of the German Empire of 1871 which
left some 20 million ethnic Germans outside of Germany and made the League
itself a global movement with local chapters in several European countries,
Syria, Brasil, the United States, South Africa, Paraguay, and the Ottoman E
mpire. The loss of the First World War limited Pan-German politics to
territorial revisionism in Central Europe. The seizure of power by the National
Socialist in 1933 further radicalized Pan-German ideology and put the League in
ideological and political competition to a new generation of radical
nationalists.
Khatami�s Islamist-Iranian Discourse of National Identity: A Discourse of
Resistance -
Dr Shabnam J. Holliday, University of Plymouth
The paper provides an in-depth analysis of how Iran�s former president Seyyed
Mohammad Khatami constructed Iranian national identity during his presidency
(1997-2005). Through a deconstruction of his speeches, it is contended that
Khatami�s discourse of national identity demonstrates a resistance to what is
perceived as Western hegemony on the international level. This is reflected in
three areas: the notion of Iranian-Islamic culture, �dialogue among
civilisations� and Islamic mardumsalari (democracy), which form the three
pillars of Khatami�s discourse of national identity. Iranian-Islamic culture
demonstrates that Khatami�s construction of political Islam is in fact Iranian
as opposed to simply Islamic. The notion of �dialogue among civilisations�
demonstrates a resistance to what Khatami perceives to be Western hegemony by
calling for Iran to be seen as an equal in the international system. Islamic
mardumsalari represents resistance to perceived Western hegemony because
embedded in it is anti-imperialism. By associating the idea of Islamic
mardumsalari with the important figures involved in Iran�s anti-imperialist
struggle, Dr Mohammad Musaddiq and Seyyed Jamal ad-Din Afghani, Khatami
established Islamic mardumsalari as the most appropriate means of maintaining
Iran as an independent nation. The research shows that despite globalisation,
the idea of the state, and more importantly an independent state, remains
important.
International NGOs and the Transformation of Solidarity in the Global Age:
The Evolution of Community Sentiment in the United States
- Dr. Rachel Hutchins-Viroux, Nancy-Universit�
J�rgen Habermas contends that, in this age of an increasingly global and
inequitable economy, a sense of global solidarity is most likely to emerge from
NGOs and social movements that extend beyond national borders. This paper
evaluates the evolution of Americans� sense of community, identity, and
solidarity in the age of globalisation through an examination of their
involvement with NGOs and social movements active in the developing world.
Notably, it examines whether Americans� social bond is being transformed from a
primarily national sense of belonging to an increasing sense of belonging to a
global community. It will thus present a brief statistical picture of individual
Americans� charitable giving habits at home and abroad, as well as statistics on
the evolution of Americans� volunteer activities related to the developing world
over this same time period. The main focus of the paper is a case study of a
recently created NGO which is active in Africa, examining in particular to what
extent its members identify primarily with their compatriots, with a global
community, or occupy an intermediary position.
Defending national identity and interests: the asymmetrical model of globalisation of the Lega Nord
-
Professor Michel Huysseune, Vesalius College, Vrije Universiteit Brussel (Belgium)
As a movement defending the interests of the richer northern regions of
Italy, the Lega Nord�s nation-building discourse emphasizes the successful
insertion of Padania (i.e. northern Italy) in the global economy. For the party,
globalization has weakened the nation-state and has hence given peoples
opportunities to acquire more autonomy. While its rhetoric exalts the virtues of
a liberal economic model, in recent years, the party has also defended the
exclusive right of Padania to economic protection. The economic protectionism of
the party finds a parallel in its defense of cultural identity. The party
accepts cultural difference only as long as diversity does not threaten what it
considers the core values of Padanian identity. The party translates (especially
in recent years) this vision into hostility towards immigration, the explicit
denial of the rights of immigrants in northern Italy, and policies that
discriminate against them. The Lega Nord hence responds to the challenges of
globalisation with a programme of asymmetric globalisation that envisions an
internal and international political order based on unequal rights and
obligations.
Living in a trans-national social space: The case of Russian academic
Diaspora -
Dr Irina Isaakyan, University of Edinburgh
Through the method of narrative biography, this paper explores the extent to
which Russian academic immigrants working in universities in the UK, the USA and
Canada identify themselves and behave as diaspora. I use the diaspora theories
by Clifford (1994) and Safran (1991), and also the concept of Faist�s (2000)
�trans-national social space�, which emerges as both the pre-condition for and
an outcome of the diasporic life. In what ways do these academic migrants
imagine themselves as diaspora? What specific diasporic networking activities
are they involved in? How strong is their affiliation with Russia, and what are
the parameters of this relationship? How is this gravitation reflected in their
new trans-national social space. My findings prove that the informants build a
specific case of Russian diaspora. I show the phenomenology of their
trans-national social space, comprised of such elements as the Soviet academic
values and the academic requirements of western Universities. I also analyse the
extent to which my respondents are ready to negotiate their social
re-positioning in their inhabitancy of the trans-national social space.
Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region
(PRC) and the Interaction between the National and the Global -
Dr. Agnieszka Joniak-L�thi, University of Berne
Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region situated on China�s borders with Central
Asian states and involved for centuries in the regional networks linking it
closer to the west than to Beijing in the east, poses a serious challenge to the
nation- and state-making schemes, especially since the opening of boundaries
under Deng Xiaoping. While open borders are necessary to improve the economic
situation of the region and to secure the supply of raw materials from Central
Asia to the booming Chinese economy, they at the same time allow much more
cross-border mobility and a much more intensive flow of people, goods and ideas
across them, which challenge the power and control of the Chinese state.
Reintegrating into the regional and global network of interaction, Xinjiang and
other non-Han dominated areas force the Chinese state to reconsider and rework
its nation- and state-making projects.The present paper analyses recent policies
towards Xinjiang against the background of the interaction between the Chinese
nation- and state-making schemes, and the globalizing influences that make them
evolve and revolve. In my analysis of the political discourse on Xinjiang I
focus on articles published in People�s Daily, governmental press organ, in the
time span of 2007-2008.
Elite strategies in a global world: A Typology of Polish Patriots
- Dr. Joanna Kaftan, University of Houston-Downtown
This study shall focus on how Polish elites reconcile the apparently
conflicting goals of economic integration and geopolitical stability with the
desire for cultural distinctiveness and territorial sovereignty. One hundred and
thirty Polish elites were interviewed ten years after the fall of communism. In
early 2009, follow-up interviews were conducted with one hundred and fifty
elites. Samples of priests, intellectuals and members of parliament were drawn
during each period. Based on this data, a typology of four ideal types of
patriots is proposed: ideological nationals, pragmatic nationals, pragmatic
transnationals and ideological transnationals. Chi square tests and the elites�
explanations illustrate that patriots differed in whether they prioritized the
defense and maintenance of a unique Polish culture or whether they prioritized
adaptation into global competition. Nevertheless, while their position on
adaptation or preservation was predictive of their position on issues such as
membership in NATO or the European Union as well as questions of support for
Catholic influence in Polish politics, these elites emphasized or de-emphasized territorial, economic, cultural and political
sovereignty depending on the specific geopolitical, historical or cultural
question at hand.
Reconfigurations of Turkish National Identity and Nationalism in the
Europeanization Process: An Analysis of Primary Schoolbooks in Turkey -
Dr. Tuba Kancı , Ko� University (Istanbul, Turkey)
Over the last decades, globalisation, and, especially since the beginning of
2000s, Europeanization processes have been influential in Turkey, bringing
various changes along with them. Turkey, on the one hand, has experienced the
rise of Islamic identity, and the Kurdish identity demands, on the other hand,
has been subject to reform measures directed at the democratization of its laws
and polity. Concomitantly, there have been increasing reactions to such
developments and measures, as well as to the European Union integration process,
and a radical rise of a 'banal nationalism' in everyday-life has been witnessed.
This paper will analyze the changes that have been brought by the
Europeanization process to the configurations of Turkish national identity and
nationalism through their reflections on schoolbooks. In countries such as
Turkey, where state-centric curriculum development and textbook
production/authorization is the practice, schoolbooks are one of the carriers of
state�s discourses. The analysis will focus on the schoolbooks of the last
decade (2000-2008) that have been officially designed and authorized for primary
education, which by virtue of being compulsory reflects mass education in
Turkey, and reflect the changes as well as the continuities in the official
formulations of national identity and nationalism in this era.
Internationalizing Nationalism: How the Second International dealt with the Nationality Question
-
Mr Michal Kasprzak, University of Toronto
At the turn of the 20th century, nationalism had become a reality which no
Marxist, however orthodox, could ignore. Many socialist intellectuals and party
bureaucrats delved into the national question, digging trenches in the
battleground over the workers� role within the nation-state. Overt nationalism
of the revisionists battled with the anti-nationalism of the radicals. The turn
to nationalism seemed threatening, not only because it reflected a more
practical strategy aligned with Social Democratic realities, but also because it
was an attempt to bring nationalism into the Marxist ideological constellation.
A genuine socialist response to nationalism required some modernization of
unquestionable Marxist tenets. But how far could the revision of a dated
ideology advance before it irreversibly transformed into something else? Many
within the Second International were not willing to test the theoretical
flexibility of Marxism, even if their practice had been moving towards
nationally oriented solutions. The battle between the radicals and the
revisionists unwittingly drew attention to the inconsistencies within Marxism,
especially Marx and Engels� inadequate treatment of the national question. These
discussions foreshadowed nationalism�s victory over socialism in 1914 and the
eventual splintering of Social Democracy
Kurdistan: Aspirational Territory of pan-Kurdish nationalism
-
Ms Zeynep N. Kaya, London School of Economics and Political Science
Occurrence of the plan of �Kurdistan� as an aspirational politico-territory
precedes Kurdish nationalism. This has led to a fixation with �territory� rather
than �nation�, and to the belated formation of Kurdish nationalism and its
problems. This paper explains Kurdistan as an �aspirational territory� and
defines three ways of defining territories in the world history: Historical,
Colonial and Aspirational. �Historical territories� have either derived from
drawing the borderlines of long existing historic political entities (Egypt,
France, England), or out of post-imperial processes and wars (Balkans after
WWI). �Colonial territories� are result of post-war colonial definitions (many
cases in the Middle East and Africa). �Aspirational Territories�, on the other
hand, are initially defined through political, not necessarily national,
aspirations for gaining authority on a claimed territory (Kurdistan, Italy,
Yugoslavia, Khalistan). They are politically-socially constructed territories
defined with the desire to form and claim a homeland or a state and appear as
the least credible and most dynamic type of territorial definition. Although
diasporal Kurdish nationalism promotes the notion of Greater (Pan) Kurdistan as
the primordial national territory of Kurds, in regards to the future, the effect
of such primordial claims remains limited compared to the role of chance
historical circumstances and power-politics.
Globalisation, Identity and �Cosmopolitan Nationalism� within Kurdish
Diasporic Spaces -
Dr Sarah Keeler , University of Exeter
One result of globalisation from the point of view of studies in migration
has been its impact on the diasporic consciousness of various migratory groups
in Europe and beyond. This paper is an anthropological case study looking at
young Kurds in diaspora and the ways in which they fashion identities which
challenge ahistorical, fixed readings of both Kurdish national identity and
political conflicts posited by scholars and dominant Kurdish political voices
alike. Drawing on their migratory experience as �global citizens�, they position
themselves vis a vis older generations which they see as fixed both
geographically and ideologically in a space that denies diasporic migration and
the potential benefits to identity formation which it entails. In so doing, they
are active in fashioning novel forms of �cosmopolitan nationalism� which draw on
hybridity and the performance of identity in globalised urban landscapes.The
transnationalisation of specific national(ist) identities through the mechanism
of diaspora allows us to consider the processes whereby phenomena associated
with globalisation, such as migration, function to fragment and reconfigure
these national identities. Using an ethnographic approach which looks at the
everyday social realities of diasporans also reframes discussion of national
identities to consider their pluralistic, heterogeneous dimensions and the ways
in which global mobility calls for a continual renegotiation of belongings and
identity. Kurdish youth in diaspora simultaneously feel a loyalty toward and
pride in their ethnic heritage, while challenging essentialist readings of their
diasporic or national identities through tropes of cosmopolitanism and �global
citizenship�, as the present case study demonstrates. Contextualised in terms of
local responses to globalisation, the paper addresses the broad themes of the
ASEN conference both theoretically and empirically, particularly those of Global
Migration Patterns and National Identities, and Globalisation and New Forms of
Nationalism.
International Influences - Danger or Liberation? Internationalism and Nationalism in Early 20th century Art-criticism
-
Dr Andrea Kollnitz, Stockholm University
In the years around the first world-war art-critical reactions on modern art
display a deeply split attitude towards international influences. My paper
investigates interactivities between ideals of international openness and
national autonomy in the cultural context of rising modernism. Two kinds of
art-exhibitions are concerned. Firstly exhibitions proclaiming modernism by
assembling artists from different countries, e.g. international
"Post-Impressionists" exhibited in London 1910 � an exhibition famous for being
strongly influential on the international development of modern art. Secondly
multinational exhibitions as the great "Baltic exhibition" in Swedish Malm�,
where several nations exposed their cultural production but in clear distinction
from each other and consequently were interpreted by specific national
characteristics and as closed identities. By analysing art-critical texts and
exhibition-programmes, I want to show how the concepts of internationalism and
nationalism interact in a cultural and artistic modernistic context, how they
can be connected to the positive or negative reception of artworks and which
various functions they have in progressive and conservative art criticism. The
national-international problematic of this period can be seen as an important
step towards globalisation in art and modern culture.
Bosnia�s �octopus of crime�: Transnational networks and post-conflict nationalism
-
Dr Denisa Kostovicova and Dr Vesna Bojicic-Dzelilovic, London School of Economics and Political Science
The paper challenges scholarly perspectives on globalisation and nationalism
that posit a conceptual separation of the two. Instead, we propose that
nationalism, and, in particular, post-conflict nationalism, is not a response
but a part and parcel of globalisation. Its persistence can be explained by the
operation of transnational networks that comprise the infrastructure of �shadow�
globalisation. Drawing on substantial original research in Bosnia-Herzegovina,
the paper demonstrates that Bosnian Croat ethnic nationalism in the post-Dayton
period can be attributed to transnational networks forged during the conflict.
Using an example of networks centred on the Bosanskoherzegovacka Bank, the paper
shows how ethnic nationalism is used as a source of legitimisation for the
group�s political, business and military elite connected by illicit profit and
personal enrichment, while eroding the state capacity and undermining the rule
of law of the Bosnian state. The paper first presents the existing approaches to
explaining nationalism in the global age, and reflects on post-conflict
nationalism. It goes on to discuss a �dark side� of globalisation in the context
of a weak state, and concludes with an empirical section explaining Bosnian
Croat nationalism in post-Dayton Bosnia-Herzegovina.
Imagining ourselves beyond the nation? Exploring cosmopolitanism in relation
to mediated representations of distant suffering -
Ms Maria Kyriakidou, London School of Economic and Political Science
The mediation of distant suffering has been at the centre of a broader debate
about the role of media in fostering a global public, which supersedes the
national imagination. The global media coverage of traumatic events, such as 9/11 or the Southeast Asian Tsunami, it has been argued, has resulted in
the fostering of relations of responsibility towards distant others and the
emergence of post-national or cosmopolitan solidarities. This paper will address
this broader discussion drawing upon a study of Greek audiences and their
responses to media coverage of distant disasters. The focus will be on the ways
people discursively construct their concepts of space and belonging, when
talking about distant suffering. The paper will illustrate the continuities and
disconnections of a mediated cosmopolitan public focusing on the interplay
between cosmopolitan and national discourses. Cosmopolitanism as a form of
global solidarity, it will be argued, is a rather elusive and vulnerable
condition, heavily dependent on media representational practices and conditioned
by national and cultural biases and interpretations. As such it is not an
impartial world-perspective but rather a rooted, locally and nationally,
openness to distant others.
Diaspora politics in the 18th Century: The British Intervention in Favour of the Jews of Bohemia
-
Mr Barak Levy-Shilat, London School of Economics and Political Science
It is common to assume that the influence of diaspora communities on the
foreign policy of the countries in which they reside is a new phenomenon, caused
by the increase in migration, and the improvement in means of communication.
However, we can find evidence of such influences on British Foreign Policy from
a much earlier period. During the War of Austrian Succession, Queen Maria
Theresa ordered the expulsion of Jews from Bohemia. The expelled Jews requested
help from Jewish communities around Europe. The leaders of the Ashkenazi Jewish
community in Britain petitioned King George II and asked for the British
government�s intervention in favour of the Jews in Bohemia. Britain, through its
ambassador in Vienna acted to persuade Maria Theresa to revoke the expulsion. I
try to examine this episode through my theoretical framework, in order to
understand why certain elements in the community appealed for help from the
government, while others chose the route of financial support. I will also try
to interpret the actions of the British government in intervening in this case.
From this early example I wish to shed light on the ways in which Jews in
Britain try to influence their Government�s policy in support of Jewish
objectives abroad.
Globalizing the 'Principle of Nationality'
- Professor Andre Liebich, Graduate Institute, Geneva
Like the concept of "globalization," the "principle of nationality"
�understood, in modern terms, as the injunction that state and nation should
coincide - emerged, in its time, as both a shorthand statement of underlying
historical trends and a programmatic slogan justifying and promoting these
trends. The paper suggests that the "principle of nationality," formulated in
its original European liberal context as a straightforward moral and
programmatic statement, turned out to be endowed with such inherent plasticity
that it allowed itself to be played out in multiple and contradictory ways as
the principle underwent its initial globalization. "Nationality" emerged as an
adaptable tool of state affirmation not only on a local but on a global level,
serving to underpin imperial domination abroad and to justify an onslaught on
minorities at home.
Kenya�s New Indigenes: Negotiating Local Nationalisms in a Global Context
-
Dr Gabrielle Lynch, Leeds University
It is often assumed that modern African ethnicities are clear, fixed and
bounded. However, regional or ethnic identities are still subject to negotiation
and renegotiation, as local actors make use of ethnicity and nationalism�s
conceptual vagueness, and local realities of complex and contested communal
histories, to redefine themselves as a means of furthering local interests in a
changing world. One noteworthy phenomenon is the impact that new global forums
and discourses regarding the rights of indigenous and minority groups has had on
debates and action at the local level. This paper examines the case of the
Sengwer and Ogiek communities in western Kenya, and analyses their recent
assertion of difference on the basis of �indigeneity�. Particular attention is
given to the choice of language employed. The paper argues that local leaders
have consciously employed �global discourses� of �marginalisation�, �minority
rights�, �indigeneity�, and �environmental protection� as a way to strengthen
claims, and as a way to gain access to new domains of action and cultivate new
channels of patronage. The paper provides a clear example of the tension between
globalisation and factionalism; as developments at the global level provide new
opportunities and incentives to re-negotiate local or regional �nationalisms�.
Persistence of identity in Japan
-
Mr Julian Manning, Nihon University College of Art
This paper will argue that the discourse of Japanese ethno-cultural
homogeneity persists because it has served a variety of political objectives
over time and continues to do so. Today we can read it partly as a nationalist
response to global trends, including the perceived failure of both European and
American multicultural models. However, it also provides structure to important
diplomatic relationships, especially in East Asia, and serves as an answer to
perceived social malaise at home symbolized by allegedly falling academic
achievement levels by Japanese students and a falling population. However, there
are limits to the power of this discourse which are increasingly evident at the
local level. The local level is where practical problems associated with
multiculturalism, such as the education of the children of ethnic minorities or
the need for unskilled labor, have to be dealt with pragmatically. The influx of
foreigners of Japanese descent since 1990, mainly from Brazil, has resulted in
high concentrations of newcomers in several regional towns in Japan. Focusing on
the case of the small town of Oizumi in Gunma-ken, this paper will argue the
nationalist discourse of a homogeneous Japanese ethno-cultural identity is being
fundamentally challenged at the local level.
Transnational Nationalism: forms of nationalism in globalized sport arenas
-
Professor Radim Marada, Masaryk University
"Logically contradictory, psychologically real", Georg Simmel liked to say
about phenomena like fashion or coquetry. The paper follows Simmel�s pattern and
it presents nationalism and globalization as perhaps logically contradictory,
but often complementary phenomena, if pursued in the perspective of
transnational experience. The argument is based on a historical-phenomenological
analysis of transnationalism in professional sport. Concrete empirical examples
are mainly taken from football sport migration and fandom cultures, but examples
from other sports (ice hockey, basketball, tennis, etc.) will also be used as
illustrations. While sport migration has been accounted for in the relevant
literature, fandom transnationalism has barely been touched so far. It is
therefore here that the paper claims to provide major empirical and theoretical
contributions. Among others, the paper documents its central thesis by the
examples of, e.g., big sport club strategies in their acquisitions of talents
(from the �third world� in particular), the role of the global media (TV and the
Internet above all), the role of geo-political contexts in shaping sport
transnationalism, etc. The historical perspective makes it clear that
transnationalism is by no means just a contemporary phenomenon. To the contrary,
transnationalism finds its stronger versions in the past rather than in the
present.
�Cuisine Fran�aise� versus �Mc World�: The Politics of Gastronomy as a Banal
Nationalism�s Response to Globalisation in France -
Mr Vincent Martigny, Sciences Po Paris
This paper argues that the politics of gastronomy illustrate in France a form
of banal nationalism and a reaction towards globalisation. This hypothesis
builds on the concept of banal nationalism defined by Michael Billig (1995) as
an ideology in which national sentiments are widely diffused and in which "the
private domain flourished within the cradle of the nation." The French
conception of food relates to both the private and the public spheres. Within
French culture, the national gastronomy conceived as a form of craftsmanship
echoes the idea of a uniqueness of the nation versus the standardisation meant
by globalisation and epitomised by American global brands such as Coca-Cola and
Mc Donald�s. By showing how for instance, Mc Donald�s was opposed to Roquefort,
the local cheese produced in a rural part of France, the French food debate has
been revolving around the affirmation of a banal nationalism expressed in non
political � i.e cultural terms. Indeed in this case, gastronomy refers not only
to a specific art de vivre symbolic of the French civilisation, but also to a
conception of French identity grounded into an attachment to a partly fantasised
conception of the rural world. This form of banal nationalism has been a
privileged path taken by French civil society � partly supported by the
government � to come to terms with globalisation.
Nationalism and the peacekeeping discourse. Political and military viewpoints
- Dr Asta Maskaliunaite, Baltic Defence College
The changing nature of conflicts after the end of the Cold war demanded that
the national armed forces shift their focus from the territorial defence to the
deployment in far-away countries. While this idea of engagement in distant
conflicts (particularly by the so-called great powers) was not novel, it
underwent a significant transformation, the most important of which is new-found
weight of humanitarian concerns.What is often overlooked, however, is that such
seemingly idealistic reasons of the attempts to stop the conflicts around the
world often get enmeshed with the more "practical" concerns voiced as "national
interest." In many cases the participation in peace-support operations is
explicitly coined in terms of enhancing own state�s security or the
international standing. In this presentation, therefore, I would like to explore
expressions of nationalism (in the peacekeeping discourse. Focusing mainly on the Baltic states, I will explore
the political level justification for participating in the missions
investigating the "cosmopolitan" vs. "nationalist" reasons presented there;
secondly, I will look at the views of the officers and their understanding of
the reasons of their deployment in the conflicts taking place far from their
home countries.
Does Europe Cause Nationalism? European Values and Identity Construction In
Modern Armenia -
Dr Tigran Matosyan, Yerevan State University
The fact that Europe-related public discourse of modern Armenia has often
been accompanied by vigorous rhetoric on the Armenian identity is indicative of
a type of positive correlation between the spread of European values and rise of
a new form of nationalist discourse in the country. Although the
cause-and-effect relations between the two processes are apparent, important
questions remain as to the nature of this determinism. My paper will try to
demonstrate that the nationalist rhetoric of the Armenian public
discourse-makers arouse not only as opposition to Europeanization but also as a
convergent phenomenon inspired by it. I will argue that both divergent and
convergent types of nationalism have been instrumental in their nature; while
the first rose as a defense mechanism against the felt threats incoming European
values posed to the security and existing power structures of modern Armenian
society, the convergent nationalism has been used by pro-European
discourse-makers as an ideological means to back up Europe-oriented policies of
the Armenian government. Besides this, I will argue that determinism between
Europeanization and nationalism was largely preconditioned by lack of objective
information about Europe in Armenia.
Globalization, a transformed political order and new forms of Afrikaner
nationalism, 1994-2009 -
Dr Heinrich Matthee, Control Risks
The paper will discuss and analyze the diverse spectrum of Afrikaner
nationalist actors, discourses and strategic approaches during the past fifteen
years. It will also explore the interaction between globalization, a transformed
democracy, and novel forms of identity politics. The paper is based on field
research as well as a study of documents, website debates, and speeches and
actions by actors during meetings and campaigns. It will be located in political
science and international relations. The paper�s relevance is that it analyzes
the phenomenon of ethnic nationalism within a context where nationalist actors
encounter benefits and disadvantages, a recasting of identities, and new
opportunities and pressures within the context of globalization. The paper also
explores the consequences of Afrikaner nationalism's new context. Afrikaners as
a group have experienced a significant change in domestic power, status and
access to resources. They have gone from being the main power base of a ruling
elite to being a politically subordinated minority in a new and transformed
political system. In addition, almost 20% of them have left their main territory
in Africa for Europe, the USA, Asia and the Middle East. These conditions have
directly and indirectly influenced the aims, symbolic repertoire and
organizational approaches of the nationalist actors among Afrikaners. The paper
analyzes these developments and outlines several possible futures for Afrikaner
nationalists.
Voice and Participation in the European Union: Responding to the Italian Roma
Crisis
- Dr. Aidan McGarry, University of Brighton
This paper examines Romani mobilisation and activism in the European Union.
The paper argues that Brussels acts as a new space in which Romani activists and
advocates articulate interests and demands based on expressions of
ethno-nationalism. It is argued that the presence of supranational actors tends
to change the criteria according to which actors define themselves, as well as
their strategies. The debate on Romani nationalism in Europe is located in the
context of the Italian Roma crisis which deepened throughout 2007 and 2008. The
Romani community have increasingly become targets of discriminatory policies,
such as forced evictions and ethnic profiling, by the Italian authorities who
have deployed nationalist rhetoric to support these policies. The European Union
and the Romani community based in Brussels have responded to these measures
through a series of discursive interventions which strike at the heart of the
debate about Romani nationalism and integration in Europe. Roma are a
transnational nation without a kin state to advocate and lobby on their behalf
therefore the EU acts as both a site and ally for expressions of
ethno-nationalism through which Roma advance claims and articulate interests.
No Surrender: Orange-Canadian Unionists and Northern Ireland, 1919-1925
-
Dr Robert McLaughlin, Pennsylvansian State University--Altoona College
Just as they had done in 1912-1914, Ulster unionists turned to their
Orange-Canadian unionist brethren for support in their time of crisis.
Possessing an unquestioning devotion to their Ulster co-religionists and a
belief that the integrity of the Empire depended on their steadfast resolve,
Orange-Canadian unionists provided both moral and financial assistance to their
Ulster brethren, in whatever amounts they could, in this most recent incarnation
of the Battle of the Boyne. These expressions of transnational support extended
by Orange-Canadian unionists to their Ulster brethren emanated from an
overwhelming sense of ethno-religious identity and connection between peoples of
British Protestant heritage, and from an Orange-Canadian unionist world-view of
those possessing differing faiths and political views as being engaged in a
worldwide conspiracy to defeat the upholder of liberty and Protestantism�the
British Empire. This Orange-Canadian unionist vision of a world-wide conspiracy
designed to bring down the British Empire incorporated such disparate
co-conspirators as Muslims and Mormons, all the while insisting that the
conspiracy was Vatican led and engineered by Irish republicans. When, in
December 1921, the British Government actually negotiated a settlement with the
southern Irish rebels and provided them with the legislative and military
apparatus to possibly dismember the fledgling Northern Ireland state-let,
Orange-Canadian unionists felt compelled to act. In this regard, Orange-Canadian
unionists, of whom Canadian Orangemen formed the most significant portion,
contributed hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide for the armed defense of
the Protestant portion of the north of Ireland. Through their words, deeds, and
actions, Orange-Canadian unionist provide an example of the extent to which
ethnic nationalism transcended national boundaries in the early twentieth
century.
Identity withdrawal within the "planetary village:" a comparison between the
British National Party and French National Front in the face of "globalization"
- Dr Djamel Mermat, University of Lille 2
The term "multiculturalism" refers to the coexistence of different cultures
within the same space, and the public policies linked to their establishment.
Now, whether arguing for "differentialism" or a singular interpretation of the
peoples�right to joy of their independacy, the radical right in the United
Kingdom and in France has known how to profit from an acerbic critique of the
official recognition of communities within/or in competition with the national
community. Thus, by stimulating a self-protective reflex in the face of multiple
insecurities associated with the phenomenon of "globalization", the British
National Party and the National Front received an inequal echo in the population
of their country. Subsequently, discursive transfers between the BNP and the NF
reveal some neighboring lines of argumentation. The ultimate goal of our paper
is to highlight this on three points: the eventual reclassification of elements
defining what constitutes, respectively, "a British citizen", or a "French
citizen" ; the question of accepting Muslim religious rites, places, and
financing, and the institutionalisation of their representatives on national
territory ; the issue of the rhetorical treatment of the flashover in the
suburbs, the methods recommended by each party to solve the problem, and their
instrumentalization in the debate on migratory shifts.
Extroverted and introverted types of nationalism and their responses to
European integration: evidence from Spanish and Polish right-wing political
parties
- Dr Madalena Meyer Resende, Universidade Nova de Lisboa
The paper explores the re-elaboration of nationalism in the ideologies of
right wing conservative parties in Poland and Spain from the time of
democratization (1975 in Spain and 1989 in Poland) to 2005. Thepaper analyses
the reformulation of conservatives' national conceptions in terms of their
acceptance of internal pluralism and their support for supranational political
communities. The reformulation of nationalism from a unitary vision of the
nation characteristic of National Catholicism gave place to a pluralist and
heterogeneous concept of the nation that accepts and eventually advances
supranational integration. The continuity between a pluralist concept of nation
and the support for political supranationalism derives from the acceptance of
the compatibility between particularistic identities and a common sharing of
cultural links that underpins the pooling of sovereign powers. Introverted
nationalists see the unity of the nation, and its exclusivity regarding other
national identities, as threatened both by internal ethnic cleavages and the
participation in supranational political entities. While conservative political
thought at the time of transition was in both countries dominated by an
introverted conception of nation, the rise of sub-national parties in Spain has
triggered the formulation of a pluralist view of Spain as a nation of nations
which supports Spain's participation in the European Union by the Popular Party.
In Poland the introverted conception of nation has remained the ideology
underpinning successive nationalist and conservative right-wing parties.
Bringing the Nation back in: Nationhood, Seriality, and Global Communication
- Ms Sabina Mihelj, Loughborough University
Modern information and communication technologies are often singled out as a
key ingredient in globalization processes, providing the basis for the expansion
and intensification of global connections and networks. At the same time, the
modern media have also played a crucial role in the global spread of national
imagination, and continue to be involved in the reproduction of nationalism
despite the ongoing intensification of global media flows. It is impossible to
understand this double-edged role of the modern media without acknowledging that
nation formation and globalization are closely intertwined rather than simply
antithetical. This paper conceptualizes the relationship between
nation-formation, globalization and modern communication by drawing on Benedict
Anderson�s (1998) notions of �seriality� or �modularity� of national
imagination. It argues that the rise of global forms and institutions of mass
communication inevitably involves the adoption of standardized systems of
managing difference, all of which take the national form as their basic unit.
The paper demonstrates the utility of this conceptual framework by examining
selected historical and contemporary cases, including the creation of
international broadcasting organizations, the national reporting of global
events, and the emergence of an international regime for governing the Internet.
The End of Globalisation, The End of Nations
-
Dr Steven Mock, London School of Economics and Political Science
One of the great straw-men in nationalism studies is whether globalisation
will spell the end of nations and nationalism. The answer, as always, is no. If,
as Ernest Gellner hypothesized, the modern nation is intrinsically linked to the
industrial growth-economy, then while expansion and extension of the growth
economy might cause shifts in the structure of nations, the basic relationship
between culture and organisation posited as characteristic of the modern world
of nations remains fundamentally unaltered.But will this always be so? Recent
theorists have argued that exponential economic growth on a global scale cannot
be sustained indefinitely. Some have pointed to indicators � such as
environmental degradation and the decreasing availability of energy resources -
that we may witness the decline of the global growth-economy within this
generation. What would this mean for the nation? Can nations endure in a global
"steady-state" economy? Or could it be that not globalisation, but rather the
end of globalisation will spell the end of nations? And while some might praise
this as progressive, nationalism theorists have also enlightened us to the many
values and instrumentalities taken for granted in the modern world
interdependent with the construct of the nation, from popular sovereignty and
mass political participation, to human equality and social mobility, to literacy
and mass public education. This indicates what we could stand to lose should
values necessary to the growth economy cease to serve a functional purpose,
opening vital normative questions as to what values we wish to preserve in a
post-modern world along with practical ones as to how this can be accomplished.
CosmoPoles: The European Identity of Higher Educated Polish Youth in a Comparative Perspective
- Mr Jeroen Moes, Radboud University Nijmegen
An identification with Europe has emerged � at least to some extent � while
national identifications on the continent have not faltered as a result. The
presented article investigates the 'width' and 'depth' of this phenomenon by
first conducting a cross-national comparison, and then performing an in-depth
analysis of what it actually 'means' to be both national and European. For the
first part of this argument, citizens of European nations are compared
cross-nationally. After this quantitative evaluation, a qualitative analysis
follows, in which the conceptualization of 'Europe' and the nation among Polish
higher educated youth is investigated. For them, being 'Polish' and being
'European' are not mutually exclusive. Instead, they distance themselves from
certain aspects of the 'national past' which they see as problematic. An
important concept by which this differentiation is performed, is the
'generation'. They see themselves as being highly patriotic, while ultimately
belonging to the 'European generation'.This is a 'Mixed Methods' study, in the
sense that the results of quantitative and qualitative analyses were used in a
complementary fashion. The study also has a multidisciplinary theoretical
foundation. Nevertheless, it is predominantly grounded in (quantitative)
Sociology and (qualitative) Cultural Anthropology.
Nationness in the Absence of a Nation: Narrating the Prehistory of the Greek National Movement
-
Mr Vasilis Molos, New York University
In February 1770, in the midst of the Russo-Ottoman War of 1768-1774, the
Peloponnese erupted in violence, in what has since come to be known as the
�Orlov Revolt�. This paper will broadly consider the extent to which this
historical event can be conceived of as an uprising of a �nation�, but, more
specifically, will gauge whether it is appropriate to narrate the prehistory of
the Greek national movement with reference to a �nation�. The argument advanced
is that the Orlov Revolt was a unique historical moment brought about by the
temporary convergence of disparate interests, which engendered the possibility of nationness and
national imagining. By demonstrating that (i) the putative nation vanished at
the moment when the uprising in the Peloponnese failed, and (ii) that this did
not serve to inhibit nationness, I seek to highlight what seems to be a paradox:
nationness remains a possibility in the absence of a putative nation, or a
nationalism for that matter. In this way, the Orlov Revolt seems to suggest that
our understanding of the manner in which nationness relates to nation and
nationalism warrants reconsideration.
Diasporic Hindu nationalist discourse over representation of Hinduism in school texts in America
-
Dr Deepa Nair, Appalachian State University
Westernization has always been seen as a threat to the �pristine� Hindu
identity by Hindu nationalists in India, yet in recent years the primary impetus
to Hindu nationalism has come from diasporic Hindu communities living outside
the territorial boundaries of South Asia. The rise of a �patriotic� Hindu Indian
community in the United States and its promotion of a militant Hindutva
nationalism cannot be regarded merely as an immigrant attachment to the
pithrabhoo. Various Hindu Indian communities within the United States are
funding activities of Hindu nationalist groups in India. This support stems from
the feeling of being a racial minority in the United States and a need to obtain
recognition of their ethnic and cultural heritage. This paper focuses on the
discourse in the United States over representation of Hinduism in school texts
in America and India. By conducting ethnographic research in various Hindu
organizations in North Carolina and an analysis of text books as well as other
secondary sources ( internet, newspapers, magazines devoted to Hindu nationalism
in America), it explains the reasons for the rise of a diasporic Hindu
nationalism and its interest in the representation of an Indian i.e. a �Hindu�
past in school textbooks, leading to a revival of national and ethnic pride.
Nationalism and the Globalisation of Multiculturalism
-
Dr Ephraim Nimni, Queen�s University Belfast
In the last 25 years, multiculturalism has spread like a spread like wildfire
across the four corners of the globe. Originating in Canada, multiculturalism
rapidly moved to the US, Europe (west and east), India, Singapore Russia,
Australia, Argentina and Japan among many. Like nationalism, Multiculturalism
has a chameleon-like format as it takes many forms and characteristics. It is
furthermore the other side of the coin of the process of globalization and
spreads with it. As multiculturalism shares many common features with
nationalism it has been nominated by key advocates of multiculturalism as the
"post-nationalist" movement par excellence, destined to supersede nationalism.
Contrary to this, the aim of this paper will be to argue with examples the
precise opposite: that the globalisation of multiculturalism does not weaken
nationalism but on the contrary reinvigorates it. It supersedes earlier blind
spots such as the 20th century nationalism�s uncompromising relation with
nation-states and incorporates e demands of stateless nationalisms. In a 21st
century globalised world, Nationalism and multiculturalism will remain the
closely related twin forms of the politicisation of identities.
The Globalization of Justice and the Transferability of Protest
-
Professor Atalia Omer , University of Notre Dame
The paper explores the global transferability of vocabularies of protest from
one national context to another as a mode of empowerment and vindication of
struggles against injustice and structural violence. The main argument is that
global norms as enshrined in the conventions of the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights (UDHR) and subsequent documents provide (a) a universal (global)
language for the articulation of conditions of injustice by subaltern groups in
specific national contexts and (b) recognition of common patterns of injustice
and thus also of the necessary criteria for the just transformation of inter-
and intra-national conflicts, (c) this recognition of the similar patterns of
oppression also suggests the possibility of cross-national coalition building
and the global aspects and implications of each local instance or perception of
injustice and struggle for national reform, finally (d) appreciating the
distinctness yet similar patterns of domination against which subaltern groups
need to articulate their counter narratives of nationhood and articulate their
grievances through an appeal to universal norms.
Illiberal Liberalism: Cultural Restrictions on Migration and Access to
Citizenship in Europe
- Mr Liav Orgad, Harvard University
This article addresses a simple but important and understudied question: Is
culture a legitimate criterion for regulating migration and access to
citizenship? While focusing on Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, I describe how these states embrace illiberal
migration policies which violate the same values they seek to protect. I then
suggest a two-stage set of immigration-regulation principles: In the first
stage, immigrants would have to follow some structural liberal-democratic
principles as a prerequisite for admission; in the European context, these
principles can be based on the Copenhagen Political Criteria. In the second
stage, as part of the naturalization process, immigrants would have to recognize
and respect essential constitutional principles of a specific state. I call this
concept �National Constitutionalism�.
�Arab Banal Nationalism: Al-Jazeera and the flagging of Arab identity during the 2008 Beijing
Olympics�
- Mr Chris Phillips, London School of Economics and Political Science
One of the most visible signs of Globalisation in the Arab world has been the
dramatic growth of new Pan-Arab television stations. Whilst Arab television used
to be limited to a few government channels, Al-Jazeera and its competitors now
offer audiences from Morocco to Oman hundreds of modern and highly popular
programmes. For the first time, Arabs from different states are able to watch
the same television shows at the same time. By connecting living rooms across
the Arab world, is pan-Arab television creating a new imagined community? Is it
reviving Arab national identity? In 1995 Michael Billig claimed that Western
national identities are sustained on a day-to-day level by being �flagged�
constantly in a state�s institutions, notably the print media. This paper seeks
to expand upon and challenge his Banal Nationalism thesis by applying it to a
case study of Al-Jazeera�s coverage of the 2008 Beijing Olympics. This study
will demonstrate that Billig�s methodology can be successfully applied beyond
the print media into a discourse analysis of television reporting � a more
appropriate method in parts of the world with low literacy levels. It will also
challenge Billig�s assumption that media confined to state boundaries alone can
flag identity, by illustrating Al-Jazeera�s emphasis on its audience�s
supra-national pan-Arab ties. Though its reasons may be more commercial than
political, this study suggests that Al-Jazeera speaks to its audience as if they
belong to one single Arab nation.
Everyday Nationalism as neo-Localism. The "Gypsy problem" in Italy between migration and national contexts
- Mr Giovanni Picker, University of Milan-Bicocca
This paper examines the emerging Italian neo-localism (Stacul 2006) through
an analysis of the construction of cultural boundaries set up by different
definitions of the "Gypsy problems" in the public discourse of two Italian urban
contexts, Florence and Pescara, in comparative perspective. Although these two
cities present similar patterns of socio-spatial marginality of Roma/Gypsies,
for the majority of Roma/Gypsies live in periphery semi-isolated areas, in
Florence Roma/Gypsies are immigrants mainly escaping from the Yugoslav wars,
whereas in Pescara they are national citizens. Based on ethnographic fieldwork
carried out in 2007 and 2008, the paper provides empirical evidence on the fact
that common sense racism and everyday nationalism assume heavier and more
violent connotations in the case of discourses on local traditions and
preservation of autochthony vis-�-vis national Roma/Gypsies in Pescara, rather
than in the bureaucratically regulated context of immigrants in Florence. I
discuss three main causal factors of this phenomenon: the higher
de-politicization of the "Gypsy problem" in Pescara in comparison with the case
of Florence; the lack of an influential Roma organizations in Pescara, contrary
to Florence where there is a rather powerful Roma organization; and the absence
in Pescara of a social rights discourse, in favor of a cultural(ist) one,
contrary to Florence, where together with culture-based argumentations, there is
a tradition of social citizenship-based claims. The conclusion is a discussion
on the forms of nationalism such as neo-localism, which are gaining considerable
attraction, being forces of social closure with scarce attention by the
political power.
Nationalism as a Weapon in Global Conflict: The Indo-Irish-German Conspiracy of World War I
- Professor Matthew E. Plowman, Waldorf College
Indian and Irish nationalists were used as a global weapon by Germany against
Britain during World War I. This was an attempt by Indian nationalists, Irish
republicans, and German operatives to smuggle American arms to India for a
revolt against the British Raj during the war. The conspiracy failed and an
American investigation and trial followed with Ram Chandra, the leader of the
Hindustani Gadar Party, shot dead in the courtroom. This paper counters
established scholarship that the Germans created or even managed the Indo-Irish
network by elevating Irish leadership such as Larry de Lacey and Father Peter
Yorke. There were Irish attempts to get guns to India before the war. Yet, it
was German wartime resources that converted the Indo-Irish machine into a truly
global weapon with conspiracy leaders in San Francisco, New York, Berlin, and
Constantinople, directing activities across the globe. American authorities and
British intelligence services had to be overhauled in structure and protocol to deal with the global extent of these activities.
Globalisation of Indo-Irish nationalism within the context of a global war both
helped and hindered the success of their organizations. There is also a lesson
about the inclusivity and realpolitik of globalised nationalism that speaks to
the 21st century.
Promoting the Dragon: National Identity and the Construction of Wales as an International Actor
-
Mr Brieg Powel , University of Plymouth
The Welsh Assembly Government declares its intention to �raise the profile of
Wales and stamp [Wales�] unique identity on the world stage�. Currently, the
Assembly Government supports sixteen different offices on four different
continents, including offices in New York, Brussels, Dubai and Tokyo. Drawing on
elite interviews and textual analysis, this paper explores the nature of the
identity which the Assembly Government seeks to promote. Understanding this
identity may prove instrumental in understanding Wales� future role in the
world. As Kalevi Holsti (1983) argues, the manner in which an actor perceives
its role in the world is a product of its own society�s historical, cultural and
societal development. Paradoxically, this very identity can in turn be shaped by
the policies the actor chooses to follow. Elsewhere, William Wallace (1991: 65)
argues that �foreign policy is about national identity itself: about the core
elements of sovereignty it seeks to defend [and] the values it stands for�.
Therefore, foreign policies are not only reflections of the identity of the
policy actor, but contribute to the construction of that very identity.
Consequently, this paper also considers the extent to which the Assembly
Government�s foreign policy contributes to existing representations of Welsh
national identity.
The Internal Divisions and Global Visions of American Nationalism after the
Civil War -
Mr David Prior, University of South Carolina
Focusing on the decade (1865-1875) following the American Civil War, this
paper will explore the ways in which 19th-century Americans contested their
national identity by discussing international developments. In doing so, it will
offer a targeted historical study that engages with broader scholarly interests
in the persistence of nationalism, the relationship between civic and ethnic
ideals, and the connections between nationalism and ideologies of
"civilization." Finally, it will suggest that while we often take globalization
to be a matrix of impersonal forces acting upon individuals, it also operates as
a process of expressing and affirming one�s nationality by describing and
interpreting the world. In particular, concepts of "civilization" and
"barbarism," while by no means unique to the United States, served as veritable
mantras in debates over America�s character and future. In the context of
mid-19th-century American political culture, discussions of national identity
therefore routinely entailed disagreements over what exactly "civilization" and
"barbarism" were. This overlapping debate, however, compelled Americans to look
beyond their own borders in search of an authoritative stance on the meaning of
these abstractions. In this way, the wide ranging nature of American political
discussions was integral to the quintessentially domestic process of contesting
national character.
Economic crisis and nationalism
- Dr Sam Pryke, Liverpool Hope University
Whatever the possible outcomes it seems unlikely � although not impossible -
that the present economic crisis will produce a resurgence of economic
nationalism comparable to that of the 1930s. Then the figure who had above all
been concerned with protecting the international market system from itself, John
Maynard Keynes, spoke in 1933 of the need to �bring producer and consumer within
the ambit of the same national, economic and financial organisation� as an aim
in itself. The subsequent period, politically influenced by Keynes, saw the
entrenchment of economic interventionist government policies besides more direct
ideological alternatives to laissez faire capitalism. The battery of controls
established and consolidated in the mid twentieth century has been by no means
abolished by the present wave of globalisation � roughly that over the last
thirty years. However, a given political goal of greater or even continuing
levels of national economic sufficiency has become untenable such has been the
dominance of economic neoliberalism. In certain respects, governments the world
over have abandoned key tenets of neoliberalism over the last six months through
massive hand outs to financial and industrial capitalism. However, there is
little indication of an ideological disavowal of trade, foreign direct
investment or overseas outsourcing, the staples of economic globalisation. My
paper examines the reasons why a full scale revival of economic nationalism is
unlikely.
Diaspora politics as globalized ethnic engineering.
The case of former Yugoslavia -Mr Francesco Ragazzi , Sciences Po Paris
Much of the �transnantionalism� literature in the 1990s celebrated the
discovery of a new sociological object : transnational communities. These
communities, often conflated to �diasporas�, were described as the new social
form of the XXth century, challenging nationalisms, holding a promise of
cosmopolitanism and post-national belonging. Much of this enthusiasm proved
exaggerated and denied by sociological and anthropological empirical studies.
While diasporic discourses and practices proved to indeed question and redefine
the nationalist relationship between identity and territory, they were no less
operating as a tool of bordering between an inside and an outside, between the
included and the excluded. Through the empirical study of the post-Yugoslav
states and Croatia in particular, this paper explores the way in which the
diasporic discourse operates when it is harnessed by state as a relatively
original modality of government. The paper explores how diasporic practices
operate as a technology of securitisation of a particular (official) ethnicity,
identified as �transnational� at the expense of the unwanted ethnicities still
residing in the territory; functioning therefore as a mechanism of
deterritorialised nationalism and ethnic engineering.
Another "Third Way". Could post-nationalism overcome the classical opposition
between nationalism and supra-nationalism? -
Dr Muriel Rambour, University Paris 1
Nations rely on shared traditions and a common culture usually built up
through violent confrontations. Deep feelings generally sustain the national
project, and the European integration process now seems to challenge this
peculiar attachment. The combination between familiar national basis, and the
European construct has frequently been perceived as a battle between rooted
national identities, and the still vague features of a European identity.
Dissociating civic and ethnic perceptions of nationhood is then pretty uneasy
and could even lead to a revival of nationalism. Instead of classically opposing
nationalism to the attempts of building any kind of supranational human
community, post-national theory helps to shed a new light on the way to deal
with multiple references and national histories in the general context of
globalisation, but also in the European framework. Post-nationalism could create
the conditions of a dialogue between the nations of Europe, appeasing their most
aggressive parts while replacing these pieces of history in a broader scope, so
that the opposition "nationalism" versus "supra-nationalism" would no more be
the unique alternative.
The Emergence of a New Form of Mexican Nationalism in San Antonio, Texas
- Dr Luis Xavier Rangel-Ortiz, University of Texas at San Antonio
Globalization, defined as the flow of information, symbols, images, people,
goods, ideas capital, and ideologies around the world and reactions to these
flows, has existed since the 1400�s. Of the four major cycles of globalization,
the last three emerged through migration flows and transnational migration.
Transnational ties have long existed between San Antonio, Texas and M�xico. This
paper examines how faster and cheaper communication and transportation systems,
political and economic agreements between the US and M�xico and political,
economic, and social conditions in M�xico have strengthened the frequency and
intensity of these flows in unprecedented ways. This empirical study focuses on
owners of small and medium size businesses identified as Mexican transnational
entrepreneurs (MTNE) in San Antonio who construct multiple identities between
M�xico and the US. Using a mixed methods approach, findings describe MTNE
national identity as a collective cultural phenomenon. The study operationalizes
MTNE nationalism using Bourdieu�s rate of interconvertibility between capitals
and suggests that MTNE networks engender a new form of Mexican nationalism in
the US.
From Ethnically based to Strategic Cosmopolitans: South Korean Citizenship Reforms since 1997
- Ms Young Ju Rhee, University of Oxford
This research examines the struggles of South Korea�s citizenship reforms in
the era of globalization as it aims to move from an ethnically-based to a
multiple belonging society by focusing on the citizenship legislative reforms
since 1997 and specifically that which applies to the dual citizenship debate.
This study finds that in the case of South Korea, 'segyehwa' (or globalization)
is fueled by ethnic nationalism, resulting in difficulty of the legislative
reforms translating into public norms in society. A significant gap exists
between institutional democratic reforms and undemocratic (or ethnically-based)
"habits of the heart" (Yang 1995:10). This is exemplified by the fact that
Korean general public as well as its non-ethnic Korean residents (or �denizens�)
still regard citizenship based on ethnic nationalistic notions, rather than as
membership of a civic or democratic polity. This paper suggests that in order to
successfully reform, people�s changing conceptions of citizenship must be
correlated with a sense of civic nationalism so that it can be used as a
constructive measure to mitigate the harmful effects of nationalism and
globalization. However, the increasingly instrumentalist views of citizenship by
both the state and its citizens as found in the dual citizenship debate limits
this necessary transformation.
Between the National and the Global: Exploring Tensions in Canadian Citizenship Education
-
Professor George H. Richardson, University of Alberta, Mr Laurence Abbott, University of Alberta
Over the last 15 years most national public education systems have added some
component of "global citizenship education" to their existing civic education
curricula. This move to expand the confines of citizenship education has
generally been applauded as a way in which schools might better prepare students
to understand and address the challenges and possibilities of globalization.
However, a close analysis of curriculum documents in Canada tends to highlight
the fact that in terms of civic education, significant ideological tensions
exists between global citizenship and national citizenship. Certainly the
concept of global citizenship itself has, as yet, developed neither the
political structures that typically ground citizenship in regularized and
generally understood civic practices, nor has it provided a powerful emotive
bond comparable to Benedict Anderson�s "imagined community" upon which national
citizenship is based. In our presentation, we will draw on Canadian civics and
social studies curriculum from across the country to examine the tensions
underlying the way in which global citizenship education has been represented
and taught in Canadian curriculum. This tension is one that pits national
self-interest and neo-liberal understandings of global interactions against the
emergence of what Graham Pike and David Selby have termed "global
perspectivity."
The EU today: beyond pan-nationalism and globalization
- Professor Alain Marc Rieu, University of Lyon-Jean Moulin & Institute of East-Asian Study (CNRS)
Through its recent enlargement, Europe did not find its borders but it has
reached its limits. These limits are not geographical because Europeans largely
identified their historical role with a political values and a political norm,
the Nation-State. Europeans never considered that this powerful norm could have
borders, that its projection could have limits. Limits were reached when the
unification process became ambiguous, difficult to organize and impossible to
manage. Unification was basically understood as the extension and adaptation of
the Nation-State model in the formation of a supra-national entity, the Union,
which should have the same qualities, requirements and a similar institutional
arrangement to the initial Nation-States. The unification was and is still based
on two processes: "deepening" and "enlargement", and two methodologies, which
are also goals to achieve, "harmonization" and "hybridization". The deepening of
the Union was always associated with the idea of enlargement, the inclusion
within the Union of countries whose history was closely associated with Western
Europe and shared some cultural and institutional similarity. Europe developed
since 1945 on presuppositions, which have now become highly questionable. These
questions cannot be avoided anymore. My goal is to analyze the situation and
explore some responses.
Internationalism and the Invention of the 1st of December National Day in
Portugal
-Professor �ngel Rivero, Universidad Aut�noma de Madrid
Portuguese national identity was consciously re-created during the 1850�. The
alleged reason was to preserve Portugal�s independence against the global threat
of internationalism. In order to cope with this goal, a full program of
socialization in national identity was then devised and deployed in the
following years. The core of this project was the proposal to celebrate the 1st
of December as a National Day. Thus, by 1861 a prominent group of the Portuguese
intellectual elite, the aristocracy and the Catholic Church, founded the
National Association First of December 1640. The aim of it was to remember the
sufferings of the nation under the yoke of Spain and the happiness delivered by
the restoration of freedom. Their program was: a) To celebrate the 1st of
December as a national day; b) To erect a monument dedicated to the heroes of
1640 in Lisbon; and c) To write a history of the events of 1640 to be delivered
among the schools of Portugal in order to educate children in national feelings.
In this paper I will provide a detailed account of this process of national
identity re-creation, an also an assessment of the failure of internationalism
and the success of nationalism.
Extraordinary Rendition: Nationalism and Globalization as Complementary
Forces in the U.S. Sponsored "Global War on Terror"
- Professor Yamuna Sangarasivam, Nazareth College, Rochester
This paper examines nationalism and globalization as complementary forces
united in the practice of extraordinary rendition. Extraordinary rendition
involves the capture of citizens and legal residents that are perceived by
nation-states as "unlawful enemy combatants" to promote the imperial powers of
NATO�s economic and military supremacy, particularly in Europe, North Africa and the Middle
East. In forming military and diplomatic alliances with nation-states that
permit the United States to transgress upon human rights and citizenship of
peoples in their own sovereign countries, the U.S. has successfully recruited
global partners in exercising the quintessential celebration of nationalism
through a unified war against "terrorists" �a globalized enemy Other. Through
the analysis of ethnographic data in the form of testimonies and video
documentaries, this paper examines the practice of extraordinary rendition that
efficaciously commodifies nationalism through the globalization of terror.
New Discourses On National Identity And Ethnic Minorities. The influence of global trends in Colombia
- Mr Jean-Paul Sarrazin, University of Poitiers
Colombia has declared itself a "multicultural and pluri-ethnic" country. New
discourses have "rediscovered" diversity and present it as a "treasure" to be
preserved. Indigenous cultures are now within the category of "national
patrimony". This implies a radical change compared to older national identity
discourses in which "tribes" were to be "civilised" and ethnic differences were
considered as an obstacle to the consolidation of the Nation-State. The new
discourses, practices and political decisions related to ethnicity imply not
only a new definition of national identity, but also a somewhat disregarded
construction of social and cultural boundaries in which some forms of
interethnic relations and cultural exchanges are considered a negative thing.
Indeed, the logic of protection and preservation of a certain "ethnic"
difference is based on what I would call "confined otherness".To understand this
local transformations, however, one must consider the context of globalisation.
The new pluralism in Colombia arises in the midst of similar ideological changes
in almost all Latin-American countries and in the same historical moment as
dominant discourses, particularly in the West, argue in favour of cultural
diversity and protection of ethnic minorities. Globalised ideas have then shaped
local definitions of national identity and of local ethnicity.
Cosmopolitanism and the cultural reach of the White British
-
Professor Mike Savage, University of Manchester, Dr. David Wright, University of Warwick, Dr. Modesto Gayo-Cal, Universidad Diego Portales, Santiago, Chile
Since Benedict Anderson�s evocation of nationalism as emerging from �imagined
communities�, enabled by the printing press, sociologists have recognised the
relationship between the ways in which symbolic forms are produced and
distributed and the formation of national identities. In the contemporary
context, strong claims have been made for the breakdown of national boundaries
in an increasingly interconnected global world � driven in large part by the
possibilities and limitations that emerge from an increasingly global media
world. It has been argued that new post-national, cosmopolitan subjectivities,
accompany, enable and feed-off globally oriented forms of cultural consumption.
This paper examines these claims in the light of data on the tastes of the white
British population collected in a large national sample survey, in-depth
interviews, and focus groups. We argue that, if White British identities are
being reformed by processes of globalisation it is, paradoxically, in an
increasingly Anglophone direction.
Transformation of an Old Conflict? The Interplay of Turkish Nationalism and
Kurdish Sub-state Nationalism within European Integration Process
- Mr Ibrahim Saylan, Bilkent University
Adopting the argument that European integration process has brought about
transforming effects in terms of the conflict between host states (and their
official nationalisms) and sub-state nationalisms, the aim of this paper is
two-fold. First, it seeks to analyze the impacts of European integration process
on the interplay between Turkish official nationalism and Kurdish sub-state
nationalism in Turkey. Second, within the triadic framework of the conflict with
the inclusion of the EU, it aims at evaluating whether European integration
process has had a transforming effect on Kurdish sub-state nationalism. In doing
this, first, it gives a brief account of the impact of European integration on
Turkish nation-state by concentrating on the reforms for democratization since
1999 in order to comprehend how the reform process has changed perceptions and
parameters of the conflict on both sides. Hence, it elaborates on the interplay
of official Turkish nationalism and Kurdish sub-state nationalism as two
competing forms of nationalism feeding on each other in new ways within the new
context. Then, it focuses on Democratic Society Party (Demokratik Toplum
Partisi, DTP) as the major pro-Kurdish political party in Turkey. Through
content and discourse analysis of party documents and interviews with party
representatives, it delves into the place and meaning of European integration in
terms of goals and strategies of the DTP.
"Do you realise you're a foreigner, and we're not used to them managing our
national team?" Using national football reporting in England to analyse
competing articulations of identity in an era of globalisation
- Dr Michael Skey, University of Leicester
Sport, and in particular football, has become a primary focus for those who
wish to examine processes of globalisation at the economic, cultural and
political level. It is also with reference to sport and fandom that scholars
have attempted to ground some of the more theoretical debates around
cosmopolitanism. Of particular interest is Cornel Sandvoss� (2003) idea that
discussions around football contribute to the ongoing (re)production of a public
sphere reflecting contemporary concerns about social identities and processes.
Drawing on this approach, I want to explore the ways in which competing national
and cosmopolitan discourses are articulated by and through the media�s reporting
of football. Analysing coverage of the appointment of the last three England
football managers, two foreign, one English, I will show how previously
taken-for-granted ideas about (national) self, other and place are becoming
increasingly scrutinised and negotiated in the contemporary era. However, rather
than rendering national modes of thinking obsolete, these debates indicate the
extent to which more cosmopolitan outlooks are becoming routinised.
Senegalese nationhood under global conditions: homogeneisation and
pluralisation of the Senegalese national identity? -
Mr Etienne Smith, Centre d�Etudes et de Recherches Internationales (CERI) Sciences Po Paris
Despite recurrent subnationalism in its southern region of Casamance, Senegal
is often described as a fairly successful case of postcolonial nation-building.
Social dynamics "from below" (wolofisation) and state efforts "from above"
("Republican integration") combined in forging a strong and routinized feeling
of nationhood in Senegal, based on the idea of its exceptionality. However,
recent trends of globalization are affecting this seemingly consensual and
"banal" Senegalese nationalism in somewhat contradictory ways.
First, I shall focus on Senegalese emigrant communities in France and the way
in which they refashion their subnational identities and politicize issues such
as language representation on the national radio and TV broadcast now available
to them through the Internet; how exile and long distance cultural
subnationalism affect their relationships to the homeland, creating
misunderstandings with Senegalese from the homelands for whom, in their vast
majority, the language issue is precisely not an issue.Thus, I shall study the
ways in which Senegalese ethnocultural communities tame globalization and
whether communities in Senegal and in the diaspora stand on an equal footing in
this respect. I ask whether these new mediums of globalization provide minority
communities with new means and impetus to contest Wolof hegemony in the
homeland, allowing for a pluralisation of Senegalese imaginations of the nation,
or, to the contrary, benefit Wolof hegemony and homogeneisation. In this sense,
globalization and Senegalese nationalism may well be both conflicting and
complementary phenomena. This paper is based on extensive doctoral fieldwork in
Senegal from 2004 to 2007, both qualitative (observation and interviews) and
quantitative (comprehensive survey on the issue of national identity). It
insists on the necessary combination of the two methods.
Immigration and contemporary definitions of Portuguese National Identity
-
Dr Jos� Manuel Sobral, Instituto de Ci�ncias Sociais da Universidade de Lisboa
For centuries Portugal was a country of heavy emigration. Economic growth
subsequent to Portuguese entry into the European Economic Community (1986) and
the economic and social trends linked to globalisation created vast changes.
Portugal became an attractive destination for immigrants from Eastern Europe,
Brazil, and the former Portuguese colonies in Africa. Nowadays the latter
represent the vast majority of immigrants in Portugal.In this paper, I intend to
tackle several issues linked to migration and definitions of Portuguese national
identity. Firstly, I intend to portray the attitudes of the Portuguese towards
immigrants. Secondly, I look upon their statuses in terms of legal rights and to
the possibilities they and their offspring have in acquiring Portuguese
citizenship. Thirdly, I analyze the implications of the presence of migrants
coming from countries where the official language is the Portuguese for present
definitions of Portuguese national identity. I will examine this case in
particular, because after decolonization in 1975 there has been a sustained
effort to maintain a special relationship in a kind of transnational community
of the Portuguese-speaking countries.
Global media, nation-bound tastes? Audiovisual media flows and cultural identities in Central and Eastern Europe
- Dr V�clav �tětka, Masaryk University
Conceptualisations of globalization are usually juxtaposed against the
cultural apparatus of the nation-state, against national identity and national
cultural representations - particularly their mediated forms which are supposed
to be eroded or at least weakened by the omnipresent transnational cultural
forces and communication flows. This paper aims to examine the validity of this
concept within the empirical context of the selected Central and Eastern
European countries and their audiovisual media. Despite of the
internationalization of ownership and the heavy inflow of imported programming
from the early 1990s on, some case studies from the region have reported a
re-birth of domestic production and an increasing audience demand for
nation-bound audiovisual contents, which is paradoxically in many cases being
saturated by commercial media belonging to major transnational conglomerates.
This paper attempts to systematize the so-far scattered empirical evidence about
the geo-cultural orientation of audiovisual media production and consumption in
the CEE region and, utilizing secondary data from the Eurobarometer and European
Social Values surveys, to investigate whether there is an association between
the popularity of nation-oriented programming, national identification and
peoples' attitudes towards processes of globalization and Europeanization.
National identity in the globalised city: Britishness and the use of
Trafalgar Square
- Ms Shanti Sumartojo, Australian National University
London's identity as a diverse, globalised city exists in the context of
multiple spatial references to unique British institutions and historical
events. Woven into its layout and built environment is a unique national story,
expressed in street names, monuments, and patterns of development. This paper
examines the process of national identity formation in the globalised city by
looking at how urban place is used and by whom. I take Trafalgar Square as my
case study, a place that acts as an imperial memorial, a protest site, a tourist
magnet and a place of celebration and mourning. I argue that Trafalgar Square
allows groups bidding for a stake in the nation's public life to become more
visible and thereby press a more successful claim for inclusion in the nation.
In addition, groups using the Square are able to claim legitimacy for their aims
through association with its history of use by other groups. In this way, it
acts as a stage upon which national membership is bid for, contested and
developed. Drawing on the use of Trafalgar Square to in 2005 and 2008, I explore
how groups using the Square engage with the notion of national identity and use
it to legitimise their own positions.
Globalization and the Nation-State: The Future of a Failure
-
Professor Ronald Grigor Suny, Charles Tilly Collegiate Professor of Social and Political History The
University of Michigan Emeritus Professor of Political Science and History The
University of Chicago
Abstract: In our new millennium, with the transnational shifts from old
centers of power in Europe and North America to Central and East Asia, three
great processes appear to be setting the agenda: the transformative spread of
global capitalism, the political persistence of nation-states, and American
military hegemony. This paper explores how economic globalization threatens the
nationstate as well as how the two work together. The roles that Russia, China,
and Japan will play after the current crisis of capitalism and the potential
retreat of American power are explored. The argument of the paper is that
globalization, a highly contested term, will continue to operate both
discursively and as the process of transformative capitalism; the nation and
nation-state will remain as affective communities; but American military and
economic hegemony will be limited.
The Politics of Language in Contemporary Europe: between Nationalism, European Integration and Globalisation
-
Professor Roman Szul, University of Warsaw
The paper focuses on glottolinguistic aspects of relationships between the
European Union and its member states (including ethno-regionalist movements in
the latter), against the background of globalisation. It tries to answer the
question: to what extent the process of European integration resembles processes
of nation-building?, what are obstacles to this process?, what are reactions of
and in member states to this process: whether European integration is perceived
as threat to or as a protection of national and ethno-regional identities?, to
what extent European integration strengthens the impact of globalisation? � all
of this from the sociolinguistic point of view. In particular, the paper
examines language ideologies, policies and practices in the European Union,
reactions to them in member states, the changing "linguistic landscape" and
"language market", especially in the new EU members, being direct or indirect
results of European integration and globalisation. It stresses some divergent
and contradictory tendencies, such as the spread of English as a practical means
of communication within the EU (including replacement of Russian and other
languages as European linguae francae) enabling emergence of a kind of European
"supra-nation", the lack of specifically European symbolic language (English is
not such a language, because, i.a. it is a global language), resistance to
English as the sole language of international communication in the EU resulting in promotion of
official multilingualism, growing linguistic nationalism (at least in some
countries), and the reluctance to European integration by English-speaking
countries iThe paper bases on official documents, statements of European
politicians, literature, information in media (from several countries in several
languages) and direct observation. It best fits to the subject "Nationalism
versus supranationalism". n the EU (U.K. and Ireland).
Rescaling Identity: Communicating Regional Identity Between National Identity and Global Competition
-
Dr Kees Terlouw, Utrecht University
Novel forms of regional identities emerge in response to global competitive
pressures and challenges to the nation state. Regions have to react and position
their identity in relation to the rescaling of statehood. The discussions on the
rescaling of statehood tend to focus on economic and political aspects and
neglect these social and cultural aspects. However, the growing autonomy of
regional administrations makes support from local stakeholders, including the
inhabitants more important. Communicating a specific regional identity is one of
the instruments regional administrations use for mobilising support. However, at
the same time old, traditional regional identities become more fluid. Regional
identity traditionally focuses on shared past and specific social and cultural
characteristics. Most traditional regional identities are institutionalised in
relation to the national identity. Globalisation, migration and social change
undermine traditional regional identity. Regional administrations now employ
different types of regional identity politics. Some present an image of a future
oriented region which can face the challenges of global competition. Other
regions still use a traditional regional identity. This paper analyses different
case studies from the Netherlands and Germany and discusses the effectiveness of
the different communicated regional identities.
National identity and immigration in Saudi Arabia: From exceptionalism to "banal nationalism"?
-
Dr Helene Thiollet, Sciences Po Paris
Since its foundation in 1932, the Saudi national identity has been elaborated
by the state as a discourse on the exceptional identity of the Saudi people but
the content of National identity has been narrowly defined by the ruling family,
the Al-Sa�ud, based on 3 factors: the ethnic and cultural background of Nadj
populations (the province where the royal family originated), the imposition of
a puritan way of Islam and the exclusion of challenging identities and foremost
its immigrant population.As the rise of oil economy has led to massive
international migrations, immigrants make up for one third of the population but
the Saudi state have implemented segregation politics and anti-integration
policy. This paper wishes to analyse how the model of national exceptionalism
based on ethnic nationalism is confronted by immigrants� communities in Saudi
Arabia. Using Michael Billig�s concept of "banal nationalism" (1995), I will
argue that immigrants are informally integrated through social networks and
consumers� practices. The classical acknowledgment of social integration
processes "from below" remains a taboo in Saudi Arabia but in spite of radical
anti-integration policies, immigrant communities tend to share features of Saudi
national culture and recasts the boundaries of national belonging.
Facebook: Flagging the Turkish Nation in the Face
-
Ms Didem Turkoglu, Bogazici University, Turkey
This paper discusses the impact of the internet, as a tool and symbol of
globalization, on the discourses of nationalism, by focusing on a new yet
popular networking site, Facebook, and Turkish nationalism. The nation as an
imagined community is realized in the micro cosmos of Facebook with the
possibility of showing off to the outside world what a nation means. My analysis
covers the discourse analysis of popular Facebook groups started by Turkish
users and image analysis of a flag campaign that took place towards the end of
2007 on Facebook. As members of Facebook, theoretically users are not bound by
the borders of nation-state. However, these borders are redrawn voluntarily
through a "mimicry" of "reality" by creating a sort of Internet citizenship
which is the basis of a struggle to form the "face" of Turkey and Turkish
nation. Based on this example, in this paper, I argue that globalization does
not affect nationalism by simply being a threat to the structure of the
nation-state but it affects the discourses of the "popular" as a symbol, by
transforming the nationalist discourse.
Holidays from history�: the 2006 FIFA World Cup and new German patriotism?
- Mr Tilman Turpin, Sciences Po Paris
The 2006 FIFA World Cup, held in Germany, was accompanied by astonished
comments pointing at something considered �normal� in other countries:
flag-waving and patriotism. The German flag, for the first time since 1990,
appeared to be everywhere � from the football stadiums to the faces of the
German football fans, hanging in shop windows and covering the rear of cars. The
Germans seemed to have � for the first time in their history � a rather relaxed
relation to their nation and their national symbols. These events, bringing back
to mind 1954 FIFA World Cup, can be interpreted as the consequence of the
ongoing transformation of the German memory landscape, allowing for �holidays
from history�. A majority of commentators in the media underscored the positive
aspects of this new patriotism � some labelling it a new �partyotism� �
stressing that �normality� finally had been achieved. After a brief summary
presentation of the comments in the written press, this paper will consider this
event in a continuity with the development of German national identity after
1989/1990, presenting the changes in the German �coming to terms with the past�
after Unification.
Survival of the Fitter: The Process of National Apperception
-
Dr Gordana Uzelac, Metropolitan University
In 1924 Otto Bauer in his essay entitled The Nation writes: �The nineteenth
century, indeed saw the most varied nations, even from distant parts of globe,
increase our cultural wealth. And despite all of this, it is impossible to speak
of disappearance of national specificity! The explanation of this is national
apperception: no nation adopts foreign elements unaltered; each adapts them to
its whole being, and subjects them to a change in the process of adoption�.
Putting aside Bauer�s implied anthropomorphic notion of nations, this paper aims
to examine how, in times of increased globalisation of the 21st century, this
process of adoption operates. The starting point of this analysis will be
Randall Collins� (2004) theory of interaction ritual chains where the basic unit
of analysis is a situation. More specifically, this paper will focus on public
cultural ceremonies, such as the Last night of Proms, as situations of analysis,
and will examine emotional dynamics of audiences within that situation. Public
ceremonies are seen as performances that have manifest and latent rationales.
While manifest rationales are often directed to a distanced global audience and
proclaimed by producers of these ceremonies, the latent ones are often shaped by
the audience that is directly engaged in face-to-face interaction. These
interactions are ones that mobilise specific emotional energy and create
cultural capitals that can be generalised as national. The paper will finally
argue that through this process, that Bauer labelled �national apperception�,
elements of �global� culture become nationalised.
Euroscepticism in radical right parties: same stance, different causality. A question of two different conceptions of national identity?
-
Ms Sofia Vasilopoulou, London School of Economics and Political Science, Ms Nathalie Brack, Free University of Brussels
This paper focuses on nationalist responses to supranationalism. It compares
the political discourse of two radical right nationalist parties on the European
Union (EU) : the French Front National (FN) and the United Kingdom Independence
Party (UKIP). Both parties are fundamentally against the EU, i.e. they reject
the integration process and wish for their country�s withdrawal. However, their
Eurosceptic rhetoric is different. FN uses a "blaming discourse" against the EU,
which is seen as responsible for the negative processes affecting the French
nation while UKIP sees the EU as a constraint for Britain to be an economic
power in a globalised world.This paper argues that these parties draw from two
different conceptions of the nation and national identity, which explains their
different Eurosceptic discourse. The French national identity has been
historically state-centred and assimilationist (Brubaker 1992) and the nation
has been the bearer of universal political values. Adopting these elements of
national identity, FN finds it very hard to cope with different cultures and
traditions in a non-national political framework. In contrast, the British
conception of the nation draws largely from the British Empire and the feeling
that it has made a distinctive contribution to the rest of the world (Kumar
2003). Therefore, for UKIP EU entry means the end of British national
independence and distinctiveness that has been historically established.
Young Elite Conceptions of British Identity and Immigrant Assimilation
- Dr. Natasha Kumar Warikoo, Harvard University
How does immigration shape views on national identity? Much has been made by
the media and politicians regarding the need to foster British identity, to
define "British values", and to outline cultural expectations of immigrants to
Britain. These pleas have critiqued the British "multiculturalism" model of
incorporation for ignoring the importance of British identity, in favour of
ethnic identities. On the other hand, new survey research suggests that
Britons-especially young and educated Britons-have weak associations with
British pride and identity (Tilley & Heath, 2007). Through 60 in-depth
interviews with undergraduates at a prestigious British university, this paper
will outline notions of British identity and "values" among young elites. The
paper compares young elite conceptions of British values and British identity with their expectations of
adaptation among immigrant communities. The former are measured through
responses to questions about British identity, and the later through responses
to scenarios posed involving cultural difference in British society, such as
arranged marriage and time off for non-Christian holidays. On the one hand,
respondents identify British culture and values as simultaneously nonexistent
and universal. On the other hand, they contrast British values with certain
immigrant cultural practices seen as particularistic and unsuitable for life in
Western society. The results show that national identity is used as a vehicle to
explain dissatisfaction with immigrant cultures, but when taken out of the
context of discussions of immigration and diversity, young elites express very
weak affinity to national identity.
"Asia for the Asians"? Japanese pan-Asianism between nationalist chauvinism and �One World� utopia (1905-20)
-
Mr Torsten Weber, Leiden University
Hans Kohn once lamented that rather than advancing "true unity" between
peoples, pan-ideologies constituted "threats to international society" and only
deepened antagonistic national consciousness. In fact, throughout most of their
histories, pan-nationalisms have displayed a closer affinity with nationalist
chauvinism than transnational cooperation. In political discourse, however,
pan-movements were frequently regarded as important intermediaries between
rivalling nationalisms and as regionalist stepping stones to peace and harmony
between all peoples in a global society. When the relatively new phenomenon of
pan-nationalism entered political discourse in early 20th century Japan it was
this regionalist-cooperative option that appealed to many liberal thinkers while
others soon realized its employability as a fig-leaf for irredentist-hegemonic
claims. Focussing on the bifurcated views of pan-Asianism held by Japanese
thinkers during the 1910s my paper seeks to explore the complicated relationship
between pan-nationalism, nationalist chauvinism, and utopian internationalism in
an East Asian politico-intellectual context. How did antagonistic political
agendas inform different interpretations of pan-ideologies? How realistic was a
political fraternization of pan-nationalism and internationalism in general and
in East Asia in particular? Can pan-nationalisms be useful in overcoming
nationalist sentiments or are they more likely to reinforce them? By addressing
these questions I will elaborate on the concept of pan-Asianism whose war-time
legacy continues to fuel nationalistic sentiments today and to impede the
creation of an East Asian community.
American Nationalists Confront the Old World, 1909-19
-
Dr Kenneth Weisbrode, European University Institute
Despite a few diplomatic successes of the American Republic in its early
years, the United States took almost a century to develop a professional
diplomatic corps. That this group of diplomats, coming of age only at the turn
of the twentieth century, derived much of its training and outlook from European
counterparts goes without saying, although the contrast this poses with other
prominent American internationalists--namely the US Navy and most leading
merchants, whose formative experiences were largely in Asia and the
Caribbean--is not well understood. What all such 'internationalists' have in
common, however, was their underlying nationalism: keen to make a mark in the
world and prove themselves up to the task, both to isolationist-minded
compatriots back home and to superior-minded counterparts abroad. This paper
follows the first group and traces the ways in which America's first generation
of professional diplomats came to think and act globally through the prism of
Europe while, at the same time, eager to refine their own, unique diplomatic
tradition. Their nationalism, then, when situated in a global context, was an
ambivalent one, as well as revolutionary for its time.
Longing and Belonging: Armenians and Long Distance Nationalism in Southern
Russia -
Dr Ulrike Ziemer, University College London
In this paper, I explore the generational differences of long distance
nationalism within the Armenian community in Krasnodar, Southern Russia. The
Armenian diaspora is one of the �oldest� and largest diasporas in Russia.
Specifically, I focus on the transnational experiences and identities of young
Armenians, who are the first generation of Russian citizens. I look at how a
sense of Armenianness and �long distance nationalism� is transmitted from
generation to generation and how regional identity politics and historical
diaspora narratives have given rise to at times a strong support for the
national cause amongst young Armenians. In this paper, I argue that most young
Armenians are inclined to see themselves as Armenian and retain a strong sense
of their culture. Yet, the notion of Armenia as homeland and cultural focus of
the diasporic imagination is no longer applicable for Armenian youth cultural
identification.
|