தமிழ்த் தேசியம்

"To us all towns are one, all men our kin.
Life's good comes not from others' gift, nor ill
Man's pains and pains' relief are from within.
Thus have we seen in visions of the wise !."

- Tamil Poem in Purananuru, circa 500 B.C 

Home

 Whats New

Trans State Nation Tamil Eelam Beyond Tamil Nation Comments Search

Home  > Tamil National Forum >  About Us & Visitor Comments > Visitor Comments 2007 > Visitor Comments 2006 > Visitor Comments 2005  > Visitor Comments 2004  > Visitor Comments: 2000 to 2001 > Visitor Comments: 1998 to 1999

CONTENTS
OF THIS SECTION

Last updated
28/08/08

About Us  10 May 2008

On the 10th Anniversary of the Launching of tamilnation.org on 10 May 1998: The Relevance of Aurobindo: Early Political Life & Teachings Sri Aurobindo on Unity and British Rule "It is a common cry in this country that we should effect the unity of its people before we try to be free. There is no cry which is more plausible, none which is more hollow...  The first question we have to answer is - can this practical unity be accomplished by acquiescence in foreign rule? ... a state created by the encampment of a foreign race among a conquered population and supported in the last resort not by any section of the people but by external force, is an inorganic state... the tendency of the intruding body is to break down all the existing organs of national life and to engross all power in itself. ...  if the middle class could be either tamed, bribed or limited in its expansion, the disorganisation would be complete...The organs of middle class political life can only be dangerous so long as they are independent. By taking away their independence they become fresh sources of strength for the Government...The dissolution of the subject organisation into a disorganised crowd is the inevitable working of an alien despotism..."  more

10 May 2007 On the third anniversary of the re-launch of tamilnation.org on 10 May 2004 and the ninth anniversary of its first launch on 10 May 1998 -  Revisted: Reflections on the Gita - 26 years ago "..That which was said by Lord Krishna to Arujna in the battlefield was both simple and fundamental - simple to declare but fundamental in content. It was a call for action in the battlefield and where else is there a greater need for action. And Lord Krishna urging Arjuna to do battle against those whom Arjuna regarded as his friends, his teachers and his relations, tells Arujna, "To action you have a right, but not to the fruits thereof."

This oft repeated statement of the Gita is of very direct relevance to all of us who are engaged in activity or action of one kind or another. The detachment which the Gita speaks about is not the opposite of attachment. It is not a dead detachment. It is not a negative detachment. Understanding the Gita is not a mere intellectual exercise in the trap of opposites.

There is in each one of us an urge to live without conflict, without opposites, to understand the whole and become holy. There is in each one of us a path of harmony, our dharma, and it is this path of harmony which the Gita enjoins us to follow. For Arujna that path was to engage in battle.more

About Us 10 May 2006  "Today is the Second Anniversary of the re-launch of tamilnation.org on 10 May 2004 and the Eighth Anniversary of its first launch on 10 May 1998. Anniversaries afford opportunities to pause and reflect. And something that I had written eight years ago, in April 1998, came to mind. It was written in response to a friend who wondered whether Gandhiam would survive.  My response was titled Gandhi and Tamil Eelam. I wrote - "I have often agonised about whether I should write at all - I have asked to what end do I write? The Tamil short story writer, Sundara Ramasamy  who was in London about four years ago told me that he had asked the same question - and his answer was that as he gave expression in words to that which was buried in him, he himself evolved and changed. My involvement in the Tamil struggle during the past several years has helped to further my understanding both of myself and the people to whom I belong. Every inside has an outside - and every outside has an inside. And the two always go together. However, I can lay no claim to infallibility...

Words which are not related to our deeds are not of much value. Gandhi walked his talk. It is when our words match our deeds that we ourselves become integrated and whole - and acquire the capability to truly serve. Each of us have our dharma - our way of harmony. It was Arujna’s dharma to do battle and it was in battle that Arujna found peace - and eventual growth. Any other path would have left him in pain and in conflict. But, the search for harmony is elusive. It was Annie Besant  who remarked once (translating the Gita), that it is better to act in accordance with one's own dharma rather than try 'to act out some one else's dharma better'. ..

The struggle for Tamil Eelam is no afternoon tea party. I remember Sathasivam Krishnakumar (Kittu) speaking to me about action in battle - how single minded one needed to be once engaged in battle. There could be no wavering. No question of a Hamlet like 'to be or not to be'. He would pause reflectively and say: "It was almost as if one was transformed in the heat of battle into another being." At the same time an armed struggle is not a carte blanche to kill and maim and lines will have to be drawn however difficult or even seemingly impossible that task may sometimes appear to be.  I believe that means and ends are inseparable... 

Each one of us will determine that which appears right to him or her - and then match his words with his deeds. It seems to me that the way forward is not to turn a blind eye to the issues that confront the struggle - but at the same time refuse to undermine those who have given so much of themselves so that their brothers and sisters may live in equality and freedom. ... Yes, I do believe that 'Gandhiam' will survive as more and more people (and that includes myself) acquire more and more courage to openly stand up for that which they know to be the truth and be willing to suffer for that which they believe to be right..."

About Us - 10 May 2005  - Today is the first year anniversary of the re- launch of tamilnation.org on 10 May 2004. On looking back,  we are reminded of the quote from Victor Frankl which appeared in our Reflections page on our first launch on 10 May 1998 - a quote which, perhaps, bears repetition, seven years later - "Don't aim at success - the more you aim at it and make it a target, the more you are going to miss it. For success, like happiness, cannot be pursued; it must ensue, and it only does so as the unintended side effect of one's personal dedication to a cause greater than oneself or as the by product of one's surrender to a person other than oneself. Happiness must happen, and the same holds for success: you have to let it happen by not caring about it. I want you to listen to what your conscience commands you to do and go on to carry it out to the best of your knowledge. Then you will live to see that in the long run - in the long run, I say! - success will follow you precisely because you had forgotten to think of it..." Victor E. Frankl, who endured years of unspeakable horror in Nazi death camps, writing  in 'Man's Search for Ultimate Meaning'

"அன்பும் சிவமும் இரண்டென்பர் அறிவிலார்
அன்பேசிவமாவது யாரும் அறிகிலார்
அன்பே சிவமாவது யாரும் அறிந்தபின்
அன்பேசிவமாய் அமர்ந்திருந்தாரே"
Thirumular's Thirumanthiram

About Us - 10 May 2004 "The world occurs differently for each one of us. Additionally, for each one of us, the world occurs differently at different stages of our lives. We grow and we change - we enfold and unfold tamilnation.org was launched on 10 May 1998 and was closed three years later on 30 June 2001. The closure led to some bouquets and some brickbats - both were understandable though, perhaps, not equally welcome! The fact that the reasons for the closure were 'personal' led to some speculation as to the 'reasons' - and that too was understandable.  The reasons were personal, but perhaps I should have made clear, at that time, that the closure had nothing to do with any external pressure. There was no external pressure. There are passages in each of our lives when, more so than at other times, we feel a compelling need to stand back, reflect upon, and learn from our life experiences. The closure of   tamilnation.org on 30 June 2001, had something to do with that compulsion and that need." - Nadesan Satyendra, 10 May 2004

Mission Statement:

tamilnation.org is concerned to tell a story - the story of more than 70 million Tamils living today in many lands and across distant seas. It is a story about their shared heritage, their rich language and literature, and their vibrant culture. But it is not a story about the past. It is a story about the present and of a people whose growing togetherness is being consolidated by struggle and suffering. It is a story about a growing togetherness which is being given fresh impetus by a digital revolution where State boundaries have become increasingly porous, not only to the market but also to informationhuman rights and political activism and where deep rooted kinship ties are finding fresh avenues for expression. It is the story of the growing cultural and political togetherness of a people who seek to live in equality, in freedom and in peace with the other nations of the world and meaningfully contribute to an emerging one world, unfolding from matter to life to mind ...

 
About Us & Visitor Comments
See also Awards, Reviews & Listings including -  the Australian National University Asian Studies WWW Monitor  top five star 5star rating to the tamilnation website. [A well organised, and extensively annotated guide to Tamil-related resources - ed.] Research usefulness [essential - v.useful - useful - interesting - marginal]: Essential
We invite your comments on the tamilnation.org website for publication here. Additionally you may send letters/articles (in Tamil or in English) for publication in the Tamil National Forum. You may need Tamil fonts (which may be downloaded here) to read the Tamil comments/letters which appear on these pages. [see also Visitor Comments 2005; Visitor Comments:2004; Visitor Comments: 2000 to 2001 and  Visitor Comments: 1998 to 1999]

From: Dr. Velayuthan Pandian, 28 August 2008

Re Karunanidhi Turns on Nedumaran  The last two lines of his poem should actually address to Karunanithi himself rather than to Sri. Nedumaran.

சீராக்கவே முடியாத சீழ் பிடித்த சிந்தை!
கூராக்கவே இயலாத மூளையில் விஷம் ஒரு மொந்தை!

It is Karunanithi's own self-assessment.

From: Kasil Hariharan, 28 August 2008

Re Karunanidhi Turns on Nedumaran - tamilnation இன் கண்டனத்துடன், எனது கண்டனத்தையும் தெரிவிற்க விரும்புகிறேன். இதுவரை உலகத் தமிழர்கட்கு தன்மேல் இருந்த கொஞ்ச நஞ்ச மரியாதையையும் கருணாநிதி இந்த பித்தலாட்டுதனத்தால் இழந்து விட்டார். இது ஒரு வரலாற்று தவறு. அய்யா நெடுமாறனின் கண்ணியம் இது போன்ற பிசத்தல்களால் இம்மி அளவும் குன்றாது மாறாக என்றும்போல் மலைபோல் மேலோங்கியே நிற்கும். மிக்க வருத்தத்துடன், தமிழ் அன்பன்

From: Nagaih Subramanian, 27 August 2008

Ayya Vannakam., Ungal pathil kandu Magilenden...Oru Samaniyan Kuda Sathika mudium yendra Veeriyam irundathu ungal Pathilil.nandri ...Naan Yenna seiya vendum Yen Thoupulkodi oravukalluku... Ramayana Anil polla nanum Yethavadu seiya vendum yena ninaikeeran...yenaium vallinathungal. Nandri

From: Sara Ananthan, Australia, 24 August 2008

This is a reply to Nagaih Subranian's letter to Tamil Nation.

அன்பு நண்பா, உனது மடல் கண்டு பெரு மகிழ்ச்சி.  என்று தணியும் இந்த போர் முழக்கம்?.  ஒரு நல்ல கேள்வி.

ஒரு சகோதர சண்டையை  ஊதிப் பெருக்கி, ஈழத் தமிழனை, இந்த இரண்டும் கெட்ட நிலைக்கு இட்டு வந்ததில் காந்தி தேசமாம் பாரதத்திற்கு பெரும் பங்கு உண்டு.

அன்று ஈழ போராளிகளுக்கு ஆயுதம் கொடுத்து  ஊக்குவித்துஆனால் இன்று தமிழ் இனத்தையே வேருடன் அழித்து ஒழிக்க கங்கணம் கட்டி உள்ள சிங்கள பேரினவாதத்திற்கு, ராஜ தந்திர ஆலோசனை, ஆயுத உதவி வழங்கி, நய வஞ்சகம் செய்யும் நாராயணன்கள் வரை பாரதத்தின் பாதகச் செயல்கள், அண்ணனை  சதி செய்து கொன்று, அவன் மனைவியை தம்பிக்கு அபகரித்துக்  கொடுத்த ராமனின் ஓர வஞ்சகமான பாதகச் செயலையும் விடக் கொடியது.

அன்பு நண்பா! ஆனால் கார் இருளிலும் ஒரு ஒளிக் கீற்றுபின் வரும் செய்தியை கூர்ந்து படித்துப் பார்.

ஈழ மக்கள் உயிர் வாழ்விற்கான போராட்டத்தைப் போலவே, வல்அரசுகளின் சதியால் தம் வாழ்விழந்த பாலஸ்தின மக்களது போராட்டமும்    மிக நீண்டது. கொடியதுசக போராடும் ஒரு இன குழுவான எம்மவர் சிலர் கூட இன்றும் அவர் தம் அடக்கு முறை ஆள்பவர் புகழ் பாடிடும் இவ் வேளையில்,    தம் இனத் துரோகிகளால் கூட  சிதைக்கப்பட்ட அம் மக்கள் வாழ்வில் ஒரு சிறு ஒளி வட்டம்.

ஆம் நண்பா, இப் பூ உலகின் நாலா பக்கம் இருந்தும் மனிதம் நேசிக்கும் பண்பட்ட நல் உள்ளங்கள் ஒன்று கூடி அவர் தம் வெந் சிறை உடைத்துப், பரிவு காட்டிடும் அற்புதக் காட்சி காண ஆயிரம் கண் போதாது.

இவ் வேளையில் உனக்கு ஒரு பணிவான வேண்டுதல்.

ஆறு கோடி ஈழத்து உறவுகள் அக்கரையில் என்று சொல்லியே, எம்மைப் பரிகசித்து, இகழ்ந்து, எம் இரத்த உறவுகள் மீது கொடிய போர் தொடுத்து, அவர் தம் வாழ்வு அழித்துக் கொக்கரிக்கும் சிங்களத்தின் சிறை உடைத்து, செந்தமிழர் சிறை மீட்க ஏன் உன்னால் முடியாது?. சொல்லு  நண்பா ஏன் இந்த மௌனம்?.  என்று நீ உன் மௌனம் தொலைக்கிறாஜோ அன்றுடன் ஓயும் இப் போர் முழக்கம்.

நீ இந்த வரலாற்று கடமையை செய்யத் தவறினால், நேரம் கெட்ட வேளையில் இந்த இடக்கு கேள்வி கேட்டாயே என்று உன்னையும், தமிழன் மீது சிங்களவர் கூடக் காட்டாத தமிழினப் பகை வெறி கொண்டு அலையும் நாராயண்கள் கூட்டத்தில் நீயும் ஒன்று என்றே வரலாறுப் பழி சுமந்திட நேரிடும்.

விரைந்து காட்டிடு உன் தமிழ் வீரத்தை!.

 இவ் வேளையில் எம் உறவு கூறிப் போந்த உனக்காகத் தமிழ் இனம்இத் தரணியிலே தன் மானத்துடன், தலை நிமிந்து வாழ, இசை அமுது படைத்து, உயிர் கொடுத்து, எம் இன விடுதலை வேண்டிக் காண மழை பொழியும், தேன் இசை செல்லப்பாவின் ஒரு இனிய பாடல்.

" உலகத் தமிழ் இனமே எண்ணிப் பார்நீ உறங்கினால் வரலாற்றில் யார் உன்னை மன்னிப்பார் ". [ see also தமிழீழ எழுச்சிப் பாடல்கள் & Flotilla lands and Gaza blockade falls ]

Comment by tamilnation.org 

From: Nagaih Subramanian [ tamilan.manian@gmail.com ] 24 August 2008

Ayya Vannakam, Nirya solla ninathau yellam maranthu ponathu .....ungal valaithalam kanndu...yendru thanium intha oyatha pormulakkam... itharkana theervu than yenna. Nanri 

Response by tamilnation.org We too ask this question from time to time. We then remind ourselves of something which Mahatma Gandhi said in South Africa more than a  century ago -

"If someone asks me when and how the struggle may end, I may say that, if the entire community manfully stands the test, the end will be near. If many of us fall back under storm and stress, the struggle will be prolonged. But I can boldly declare, and with certainty, that so long as there is even a handful of men  true to their pledge, there can only be one end to the struggle, and that is victory... It is possible that a majority of those present here might take the pledge in a fit of enthusiasm or indignation but might weaken under the ordeal, and only a handful might be left to face the final test. Even then there is only one course open to the like of me, to die but not to submit to the law..."

We also remind ourselves of the words of  Cheryl Berger

Freedom is not Free

Why do we call it freedom
when freedom is not free.
The cost was blood and sweat
and tears that bought our liberty.
...

For many left their loved ones
their friends, their families
Standing true to oaths once taken
to defend our liberties.

Holding fast they fought for freedom
both at home and then abroad
Spilling blood upon the waters
o'er the ground on which they trod.

Wounded from the many battles
in mire and blood their bodies lay
The dead with mouths wide open
forming words they'd never say.

Seeing eyes no longer seeing
hearing ears no longer hear
Hearts once beating stilled and quiet
loved ones close no longer near.

And though their hopes and dreams were shattered
let their deaths not be in vain
We must keep forever burning
freedom's torch, the victor's flame.

For they died for you, America
your freedom was not free
For t'was their blood and sweat and tears
that bought your liberty.

So when you speak again of freedom
may your hearts be filled with pride
And your gratitude for those
who for your freedom fought and died.

From: Professor Bob Rothstein, USA 19 August 2008

I cannot find two publications that you list: "Envisioning New Trajectories for Peace in Sri Lanka" (2006) and "International Dimensions of the Conflict in Sri Lanka". Could you tell me how I might find these works? I am a Professor of International Relations in the US but am currently living in London.

Response by tamilnation.org  Many thanks for your interest, You will find "Envisioning New Trajectories for Peace in Sri Lanka"  at http://www.tamilnation.org/conflictresolution/tamileelam/seminar_06_Zurich/index.htm and also at http://www.tamilnation.org/books/Conflict%20Resolution/cjpd_2006.htm

You will find "International Dimensions of the Conflict in Sri Lanka" at http://www.tamilnation.org/saty/071001international_dimension.htm

From: Harsh Raghuvir [ hraghuvir@gmail.com ], 27  July 2008

Hello, I would like to enquire as to whether your organization advocates an independent Tamil Nadu? Thanks

Response by tamilnation.org  The short answer is No. For a longer answer please see Tamil Nation & the Unity of India,  written seven years ago on 3 February 2001. The break up of India, if it comes will not come from the efforts of tamilnation.org. It will come despite our efforts. It will come from a failure of political leaders in India to openly recognise that India is a multi national state - and  recognise the enduring wisdom of the words of Pramatha Chaudhuri in 1920... more

From: Kay Jambulingam, Tamil Nadu, 26 July 2008

I am teaching Tamil in an ICSE school for tenth standard. Veerapandiya Kattabomman is one of the two text books. I am immensely benefitted from your site. I am really proud to teach about one of the earliest freedom fighters of Tamilnadu. I am grateful to you.Thank you for the noble work you have been doing. Regards.

Response by tamilnation.org  Mikka Nanri.

From: Viv Nathan, USA 20 July 2008

Re Second World Tamil Eelam Convention, Nanuet, New York, 1984. Thank you tamilnation.org for publishing the letter of reply from our National Leader, Mr. Prabhakaran dated May 19th of 1984 for the invitation letter from Dr.Winston Panchadcharam. We always compare our National leader with Israel's first Prime Minister, David Ben-Gurion who fought for the creation of a newly independent state for his people. We, the 70 million Tamils all over the globe are fortunate to have a web site such as yours to learn a lot - from our art to our culture and to our literature.

From: G.S.Vinod, Inventory Management,  Ozone Media Solutions, India, 17 July 2008

Greetings from Ozone Media. We would like to advertise our campaigns on tamilnation.org. Ozone Media is India's leading internet Ad Network with the largest Online Publishers in India as partners. We would be pleased to take you in as our valuable partner.

Response by tamilnation.org  We thank you for your interest. However we do not at present carry advertisements. Should this policy change we will certainly get in touch.
 

From: Dr. Jessie J. Mercay, Chancellor, American University of Mayonic Science & Technology, United States , 8 July 2008

Hello, I am a student of the famous architect V. Ganapati Sthapati. I want to tell you that I so appreciate your wonderful website. You have done an amazing job with all of the poetry, music and knowledge. It nurtures beauty and truth. Thank you again for all that you do.

From: Tilly Naidoo, Soth Africa, 8 July 2008

Vannakam. I am a 4th generation diaspora Thamizhan from South Africa.I have visited a few web-sites gleaning information on the essence of Tamil Heritage.Your site, however, stands tall offering invaluable information and deserves laudable comments.I am looking for an apt Tamil saying / sayings, with English translation, that capture/s the essence of Tamilhood and the rich Tamil Heritage in its totality.It must be something extremely powerful with no chinks in the wall that can be frivolously chipped at by amateuirstic viewspoints. I also have questions on the following:

1.What is the Panjangam and what is its purpose ?
2. How did the concept / celebration of Tamil New Year come about ?

Response by tamilnation.org  Mikka Nanri. You may find the information re the Hindu Panchangam at the Himalayan Academy of some use. Re the Tamil New Year please see Tamil New Year Day - First of Thai
 

From: இராஜேஷ் லெனின், MakkalTV,  Tamil Nadu, 20 June 2008

அன்பிற்குரிய (tamilnation.org) தமிழ் நேஷன் குழாமுக்கு... மக்கள் வணக்கம். தங்கள் வலைமனையைத் தொடர்ந்து பார்த்து, படித்து, பயன்பெரும் தமிழ் சமூகத்தினரில் நானும் ஒருவன். நான் மக்கள் தொலைக்காட்சியில் விளம்பர மற்றும் மக்கள் தொடர்பு மேலாளராகப் பணிபுரிகிறேன். தங்களின் தமிழ்ப்பணி தொடரட்டும், வெல்லட்டும் என்று வாழ்த்தும் அதே வேளையில், ஒரு வேண்டுகோளையும் தங்கள் பரிசீலனைக்காக வைக்க விரும்புகிறேன்.  

தங்கள் வலைதளத்தில் தற்போது இடம் பெற்றிருக்கும் யூ ட்யூப் படக்காட்சியான "வாழ்க தமிழ்மொழி" எனத் தொடங்கும் பாரதி கவிதையின் காட்சிவடிவம், எமது தொலைக்காட்சியின் தமிழ்த்தாய் வாழ்த்தாகும். இதைத் தங்கள் வலைமனையில் இடம்பெறச் செய்தமைக்கு மக்கள் தொலைக்காட்சி குடும்பத்தினரின் சார்பில் நன்றியைத் தெரிவித்துக் கொள்கிறேன். "தமிழ் நேஷன்" வழியாக உலகத்தமிழர்கள் பலரை சென்று சேர்வது குறித்து மகிழும் அதே வேளையில், அப்படக் காட்சிக்குக் கீழே மக்கள் தொலைக்காட்சியின் இலச்சினையும் இடம் பெற்றால் பொருத்தமாக இருக்கும் எனக் கருதுகிறோம். ஆகவே, இந்த வேண்டுகோளைத் தகுந்த முறையில் பரிசீலித்து உரிய ஆவன செய்வீர்கள் என நம்புகிறோம்.

Response by tamilnation.org Mikka Nanri. We have included your logo as suggested. We wish you well with your efforts with Makkal TV

From: Sheela Chetty, South Africa, 17 June 2008

Vannakam. You website is spectacular. Thank you! I live in South Africa and am a 5th generation Tamil from India. I would like to know if your website or perhaps another can give me a proper description of what a Tamil is? I was told that a true Tamilian is one who resides in a place where there is a temple. Is this true? Please enlighten me.

Response by tamilnation.org Many thanks for your comments. Mikka Nanri. It was also heart warming to hear from a '5th generation Tamil' from South Africa. It is perhaps true to say that where ever Tamils live, there is a temple near by - but that is not to say that those who live near temples are (or were) Tamils.. Today, there are temples built by Tamils in Australia, in the United Kingdom, in the United States - and in many other parts of the world. And many will agree with Prof Zvelbil's conclusion that  Dravidian Temple architecture is one of the major contributions that the Tamil people have made to world civilisation. Said that the question as to who is a Tamil is a broader and deeper question and you may find the discussion at "Who is a Tamil" of interest. Definitions, it is said, come at the end of knowledge. That is another way of saying that all definitions are incomplete. To define, we reduce the whole into separate elements. But the whole is  more than the sum of the separate parts. Arthur Koestler put it well  in Janus : A Summing Up

"....it is of course perfectly legitimate, and in fact indispensable, for the scientist to try to analyse complex phenomena into their constituent elements - provided he remains conscious of the fact that in the course of the analyses something essential is always lost, because the whole is more than the sum of its parts, and its attributes as a whole are more complex than the attributes of its parts..."

Ludwig Wittgenstein said it bluntly in his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus -

"...all the propositions of logic say the same thing, to wit nothing. To give the essence of a proposition means to give the essence of all description, and thus the essence of the world. The limits of my language mean the limits of my world..."

A story is told of Ludwig Wittgenstein (though we cannot vouch for its accuracy)  that he would ask his students at Cambridge University to describe in words the smell of coffee. And as the students struggled in silence he would quote from his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus - "..What can be shown, cannot be said. There are, indeed, things that cannot be put into words. They make themselves manifest."

From: Ahamed Roomy,Young Asia Television, Pelawatha, Batharamulla, Sri Lanka. roomy@yatv.net 17 June 2008

Dear Sir,  Request for  information regarding your article  'Foreign Aid & Sri Lanka's  Military Expenditure' -  I am an Assistant Producer of Young Asia Television a program which produce peace documenters in Sri Lanka. I would like to request you for information regarding about that article. I wish to do a documentary on that topic. Hope you will give your fullest support in providing necessary facts to make this a success.

Response by tamilnation.org  We thank you for your interest. We regret that our remit does not extend to providing assistance of the kind that you have requested.

From: P Raghunandan, India 26 May 2008

Hello, Just dropped by. What a lovely site you have there. Very deep, and broad looking with various points of view and perspectives. I read parts of the site and was very impressed. Seriously though you have gone way beyond just Tamil Nation or Sri Lanka or Eelam. All those are probably (in my view) restricting the whole canvas.

I was born a Tamil (Tamil Nadu) and I have always wondered "Who is a Tamilian?" You see (as you have stated) there are Tamils all over the world - a diaspora.

Some speak a different Tamil to say the Madras Tamil. I met a youngster from Batticaloa who had come to Madras after 1983. I didn't understand a word of what he said and he didn't understand me! Both were supposedly speaking the same language. There are Tamils who cannot speak Tamil or read or write that language. So is it only the language that defines one? Or is it food? Costume? Music? Culture? All this is so varied and encompasses the globe. Tamils have been so adaptable and taken on the cultures, fragrances, hues of the lands they settled in. They have gone beyond narrow restrictive definitions and borne roots and flowered where ever they went. So maybe Tamils are a people of the world ... I met a couple with their children in a train journey in Tamil Nadu.  They were from Denmark. He was originally a Hindu from Jaffna and she a Christian from Tamil Nadu. The children and the parents speak either in Danish or Tamil! No English. It was fascinating to watch how these different cultures had melded into forming their identity. Tamils cannot be bound by petty politicians' ways of thinking - isn't that wonderful for a diaspora?

Response by tamilnation.org Many thanks for your comments - and for having taken the trouble (and time) to write. We take on board your comment that

 'seriously though you have gone way beyond just Tamil Nation or Sri Lanka or Eelam. All those are probably (in my view) restricting the whole canvas.'

Here, you may find the views expressed by Professor Murugesu Sivapalan, some four years ago of interest -

"...I can see a seamless transition between Tamil Nationalism, Tamil Globalism as enunciated in the Puranaanuru Poem "Yathum Ure Yavarum Kelir", and Tamil spiritualism. Tamil Nation website has once again raised the standards of journalism and debate to a higher plane - fighting for freedom for ourselves is on a par with treating all of the world's people as our brothers and sisters, and aiming to achieve salvation by personal meditation and sacrifice."

Again, we believe that Frantz Fannon was right when he declared that -

"...the building of a nation is of necessity accompanied by the discovery and encouragement of universalising values... It is at the heart of national consciousness that international consciousness lives and grows..."  

We believe that a true trans nationalism will not come from a simple minded idealism which proclaims that 'the Tamils are a people of the world'. We are more than mindful that even those  who may speak about the 'one world' (and decry divisions) continue to live their lives with seeming contentment in a world divided by nation states - 'one world' for the Tamils but 'our nation' for the American, the Canadian, the French, the British and so on.  We cannot pretend to live in a 'one world' which has not yet arrived. However, that is not to say that we should not work toward the ideal of a 'one world' where the separate national identities of the peoples of the world will be transcended (but not merged) by a greater unity. And for us, the words of Mahatma Gandhi continue to strike a chord -

"...My goal is friendship with the world and I can combine the greatest love with the greatest opposition to wrong ... Through the realisation of  freedom for India, I hope to realize and carry on the mission of the brotherhood of man..."

We believe that that which is fundamental is 'the realisation of  freedom.' It is freedom that will secure that the interchange between peoples will be equal and free. "Fighting for freedom for ourselves is on a par with treating all of the world's people as our brothers and sisters, and aiming to achieve salvation by personal meditation and sacrifice". We believe that -

"A true transnationalism will not come by the suppression of one nation by another. A true transnationalism will come  from nationalisms that have flowered and matured; from peoples who have grown from dependence to independence to inter-dependence. It is only the independent who may be inter-dependent.  And to work for the flowering of the Tamil nation is to bring forward the emergence of a true trans nationalism. ...In the meantime, Tamils have no cause, to be apologetic about their togetherness as a people. As a people, we too have much to contribute to the rich fabric of the many nations of the world - and to world civilisation..."

There is perhaps one other comment that we would like to add. And that is in relation to your remark that 'Tamils cannot be bound by petty politicians ways of thinking'. We may want to be mindful that politicians do not come to us from the stratosphere. They are grown by us on the ground. Our leaders are more representative of us than we may sometimes care to admit. And  Dee Hock, Founding CEO, Visa International  was right when he declared -

"...In a very real sense, followers lead by choosing where to be led. Where an organizational community will be led is inseparable from the shared values and beliefs of its members..."

From: Parasakthy Sundharalingam, Australia, 26 May 2008

Re 'Politics not my cup of tea says US Ambassador Blake' - The comments by tamilnation.org were powerful - so were the  cartoons. People are going for movies - what a statement by a diplomat! May your service continue.

Sri Lanka colonisation of Tamil Homeland

From: Oruvan, Kattankudi, Tamil Eelam, 21 May 2008

You are absolutely spot-on in your response sir, to 'Tactical Tremors'. The key word you have employed is "more to do." You wrote: "..the tactical tremors (re SARPSCO – the newly launched, the South Asia Regional Port Security Cooperative) have have MORE TO DO with China and its String of Pearls Strategy than with the LTTE". It doesn't however, rule out completely the Tamil Tigers and their potent strategic manoeuvres in the Tamil ocean. China's capability to establish a forward presence is unquestionable. The Imperium is very concerned about such moves. But any keen chess player would know not to discount the capability of a pawn check-mating the king or even a pawn having the ability to attack the queen and take her out of the game. More over, having battled through to the end of the other side, a pawn can choose to grow into a queen, rook, bishop or knight. Its not the size or the importance. Depending more to do with the move... Tiger moves with precision. Thanks for the splendid service rendered by Tamil Nation.

From: Thedum Manithan, Tamil Eelam, 25 April 2008

In your editorial comment on Peace and 'Getting to Yes' you make an excruciatingly truthful observation which has some how by passed the major intelligentsia.

"To label a conflict resolution as a 'peace process' may well cloud our thinking."

Well said! Norway has come under the cloud of the unknowing, in terms of bringing peace in its various forms to the hot spots of the world. No where in the world however, have these Nordic nerds managed to bring peace, let alone meaningful conflict resolution. I conclude by another quote for the benefit of the little man who is seeking honourable peace:

"At the outset, we may need to be mindful that to label a conflict resolution process as a 'peace process' may cloud our thinking. A 'peace process' suggests that somehow everything will be solved when 'peace' is secured. We all love peace. But peace comes in many different forms. We have the peace of the graveyard as well. If it was simply peace that the Tamil people wanted they may have been well advised to willingly submit to alien Sinhala rule - many years ago."

During the rounds of talks between Sri Lanka and Eelam, I was deeply troubled to watch even the well-advised Tamils forego the primacy of reason and to put all their trust on Norway - even to believe that Norway would manage to secure peace and even the separate state of Eelam. Very sorry state of political perceptions.

The process of peace, Prof Noam Chomsky seem to think, is designed to be duplicitous, and its objective is to serve the grand plan of the international players. Kosovo got its independence. You among others, quite rightly, were cautious in your comments. It was indeed a SUPERVISED independence. Many were of the mind that that could create a domino effect and eventually it would act as a catalyst and Eelam would be "given" its independence. The problem is we are yet to overcome our slavery mentality. We still believe that some one else is going to "give" us what we need. Bull shit!

We must fight for it, struggle for it - hell or high water. We must get the 'hell out of our mess'. We must do it! Faith is not just clinging on to some thing. It is about daring to beat the odds. Mikka Nandri.

Response by tamilnation.org   '..If someone asks me when and how the struggle may end, I may say that, if the entire community manfully stands the test, the end will be near. If many of us fall back under storm and stress, the struggle will be prolonged. But I can boldly declare, and with certainty, that so long as there is even a handful of men  true to their pledge, there can only be one end to the struggle, and that is victory...' Mahatma Gandhi's Pledge of Resistance in Transvaal, Africa, 1906

From: Louise Coyle, International Affairs Office, National University of Ireland, Galway 25 April 2008

The National University of Ireland, Galway is currently accepting applications for the International Scholarship Programme. The Programme is aimed at developing the capacity of outstanding individuals who can assume leadership roles in their fields of study and whose work will enhance the development of their own society.

The Scholarship provides recipients with €15,000 for living expenses and in addition covers the cost of tuition fees. This programme is open to applicants from Ethiopia, South Africa and Sri Lanka. Applications should be received before 9th May 2008.

The International Affairs Office is currently accepting applications. Further information regarding the NUI Galway International Scholarship Programme including the scholarship guidelines, application form, minimum entry requirements and list of approved courses can be downloaded at http://www.nuigalway.ie/international/fees/scholarships.html .

I look forward to your co-operation in promoting this programme to suitable applicants. Please do not hesitate to contact us for further information. Queries can be addressed to international@nuigalway.ie  Best wishes

From: Stephanie Rocke, National Thesis Register Manager, Musicological Society of Australia, 23 April 2008

Not a big deal, but I just thought you may like to be aware that you've listed Toge Sankichi's birth year as 1921 - its actually 1917 (see  Richard H. Minear, "Translator's Introduction [to Poems of the Atomic Bomb by Tôge Sankichi]," in Hiroshima: Three Witnesses, ed. and trans. Richard H.Minear (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990), 277 and Robert Jay Lifton,  Death in Life; Survivors of Hiroshima (New York: Random House, 1967), 441. I've been researching him as part of my analysis of Karl Jenkins' " The Armed Man: A Mass for Peace" which sets a portion of Toge's poem "Flames". Best Wishes.

Response by tamilnation.org Many thanks. We have made the necessary corrections in our Hiroshima & Nagasaki page.
 

From: Chandi Sinnathurai, Tamil Eelam, 18 April 2008

I found Sachi Sri Kantha's short recollection on the late Arthur C Clarke most interesting. The scanned snail-mail letter from Clarke, composed on a good old typewriter shows how things have changed. Sadly things are yet to change in Sri Lanka when it comes to the politicoes and politics. How true it is that in this day and age 'regular' postal letters from friends and loved ones are so very rare. We have to live now with 'wretched' text messages ("txt language") and e-mails. However, the swiftness of e-mail communication is a thing not to be despised. But the art form of splendid letter writing, with the fountain pen (not with the ball-point!) has gone with the wind.

From: Mohammed Ghazi, Musyab, Iraq-Babylon 10 April 2008

I am from Iraq. I am Ph.D student. My thesis relates to Iraqi Armed Conflicts and Humanitarian International Law. My research focus is on the armed conflicts in Iraq after 9 April 2003. I hope I can get  your help to get sources related to this subject. With Best Regards

Response by tamilnation.org Regretfully, our remit does not extend to providing the type of assistance that you seek.

From: Stewart Sloan, Hong Kong, [sloanbooks@gmail.com ], 8 April 2008

I am Scottish, living in Hong Kong and have worked for an human rights NGO for the past 4 years. I have been appalled at what I have read about the treatment of the Tamils in Sri Lanka and would like to become more deeply involved. I am aware that you have no reason to trust me but would be grateful if you would add me to your mailing list. I will gladly provide any information about myself that you might require. http://sloanbooks.blogspot.com

Response by tamilnation.org  Many thanks for your interest. But we regret that we do not operate a mailing list.

From: Sundar Rajan, Chennai, 7 April 2008

Inspired

Hello Tamilnation..

tamizhan illidha nadu illai
tamizhannukku endur oru nadu illai



Very catchy phrase... I went through your site - it is good... keep it up.
 

From: Parasakthy Sundharalingam, Australia, 8 March 2008

War Journey - MalaravanVanakkam. It was a pleasure to see Malaravan's writing in print though the contents brought tears as well as pride about our heroes' sacrifices. Though only nineteen years of age when he wrote his memoirs he had achieved true greatness. His diary will live in history like the diary of Anne Frank and Che Guevera's Motorcycle Diaries. Three years ago Mr. Yogaraja, a writer had mentioned about Malaravan in his essay about Maaveerars' writings in the 40th anniversary malar of 'Mallikai'' - a literary magazine from Ilangkai. The writer had analysed the writings of Malaimakal and Ambuli and mentioned about Malaravan's novel found among his belongings after his heroic death. Your publication is timely, the translation is good - sounds like original. The Tamil diaspora youth are sure to welcome this hero's story of dedication and sacrifice.

Response by tamilnation.org We agree. Malaravan's writing touches our hearts because it was written from the heart. The translation by N.Malathy retains the authenticity of the Tamil original and she is right to point out that "The book reveals a lot that has so far not been revealed in reports. The book speaks for itself about the conflict and will hopefully  create an interest to learn more."

From: Soma Skanda, 7 March 2008

Sir, I would like to draw your attention towards links of two articles on the Aryan-Dravidian Question that appears on this page of your website. The two articles are one written by Mr.David Frawley and the other written by Mr.Rajaram.

I'm basically a student. I stumbled upon the said pages while trying to learn more on the Aryan-Dravidian question and further down the line, I happened to read a cover story in FRONTLINE on this aspect, and that too specifically is a critique about the work of the above said two authors in that area. So I thought it would be apt to draw your attention to it, so readers from now on will have another perspective on the issue in question.

Links to the Frontline Cover Story : The Indus Valley Decipherment Hoax - Michael Witzel and Steve Farmer, 13 October 2000; The direction of Harappan writing - Michael Witzel and Steve Farmer, 13 October 2000 and Hindutva and history - Romila Thapar, 13 October 2000

Another article about the Indus Script - Towards a scientific study of the Indus Script - Iravatham Mahadevan 4 February 2007

Thanks & Regards.

Response by tamilnation.org Many thanks for your interest. We have included the links in our Tamil Heritage page.

From: Dr. Dunton Phillips, Vancouver, Canada, 4 March 2007

Dear Editor: I have gone through your Website and I find that your website is a veritable Encylopaedia of Tamil History and News about your Very Ancient Tamil People. You and your helpers are doing a very useful work. I wish that the Sinhala leaders and their people may open their eyes and recognize your desire to be INDEPENDENT AND A SOVEREIGN NATION. It is not easy to become an independent Nation - I wish that all the Tamils get UNITED - there are plenty of Tamil Mercenaries working with Sinhala people - they are self-destructive and they live to fill their stomachs with the money they get from Sinhala government. I wish you all success in your work. You have the best website - call it - Tamil Encyclopaedia

From: Angel Sanna, 2 March 2008

Re Tamil literaure on the web, I can't believe you guys have done such a wonderful work. You know what -  I and my brother wanted to make those books as e-copies as we lost much during the war. We even planned to earn some money, go to India, buy the publications without knowing that you guys had done a WONDERFUL job long time back.

Btw, I am doing mechatronic engineering year 2 now and my thambi just entered university.

I was bored yesterday and was just browsing the net and I found your  website. I was so excited... You wont believe I was jumping, jumping,  jumping and at one stage I thought I am going to die from excitement. What a wonderful job. I tried to copy and rename the pdf files but its taking time as the internet is very bad here.

My grand parents and the closest uncles parents (our grand parents too) were so good in Tamil. So, they read periya puranam, serap puranam, thevaram etc for us as we don't know the meanings (Porul) for those verses. Dad and uncle used to read all sort of books from comics to big literature. They introduced us to the Moscow publication's books, Palaniappa brothers publication's books, Manimegalai publication's books, Vanathi publication's books etc. We had a huge room with lots and lots of books which our grand parents and parents had read. We are the new generation and we used to read lot like 6 hrs a day. Parents didnt stop us as our average was 90+ in school. I came abroad to study and didnt bring any books.

I have missed the books these two years and really felt like I am a living corpse. Grand parents are not here to explain any more. So, now when I went thru it I found difficulties to understand those old puranams. Can you do a favour. You guys have done lot. Yet, when we become old we wont be good enough to explain to our new generation the verses. So, if you write the porul also it will be really helpful. I cant wait to go back home and beg our Tamil professors to do this work.

I studied in Jaffna btw. We had Tamil literature as 40% of the Tamil O/L paper. There we had some parts on serapuranam, nalavenpa, manimegalai kapiyam, manu neethi, cholan varalaru & etc. It was so hard for others but was easy for us coz of our grand parents. One grand pa was a Tamil pulavar. We also had Saiva Samayam subject where we studied about those nayanmars and thevarams. I am so glad to read them now. I dont know if there is a error in Sambanthan's thevaram. Will send you what is that when I receive a reply coz I am just wondering if you will get this mail.

Do you have all those pdf files in CD? We can't ca